I have to admit that I'm pretty excited about the game today as I think it will make the decision as to who will be our starting QB. In my opinion, I think the coaches know what they have in Peterman, so it's Josh's job to change their mind and overall his job to lose.
With that being said, I know that it's not about statistics, but it kinda is. Results matter. Peterman was almost lights out in his performances so far, but Josh is the known future so a tie goes to the Rookie.
For me, if Josh is playing with the starters for the entire first half and shown good prep all week, I think anything about 60% completion with 140+ yards and 1+ scoring drives makes Josh our week 1 starter. Obviously there will be other factors, but if that's the result, I believe it's his.
If he does win it, I will make my formal apology for Daboll and Josh for all the terrible things I said at their hiring and drafting.