Jump to content

Beck Water

Community Member
  • Posts

    13,457
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Beck Water

  1. I think NickyLeaks should dry himself off. If the Jets are negotiating with Cook and his agent, and have a deal ready to go *while he is still under contract to another team who may be seeking to trade him*, that would be a huge case of Tampering and the J-E-T-S Jets would be in trouble with the league.
  2. Based upon what? Your in-depth analysis of his 275 snaps showing that he was, in fact, running the correct route at the correct depth, reading the zone defense correctly and choosing the correct option, getting open against zone, and catching the ball consistently? What was Shakir's catch %? His drop %? Let me help - he had 10 receptions on 20 targets with 2 scored drops (meaning the ball hit him in the hands and should be caught with "ordinary effort). You could be right that 90% of the board would agree with you, I dunno - but if so, what would that say to 90% of the board's football acumen?
  3. Morse comes across very serious in locker room and post-game interviews It was cool to see him unbuttoned a little bit His explanation of why he wears a beard 😅😅😅
  4. The actual yearly salary difference between the two was very slight - McKenzie at $2.26M and Crowder at $1.97. So like $260k. I think your read is correct that they were expected to compete/share the slot role, and McKenzie seemed to be ahead of Crowder in camp. Crowder did not "get" the starting slot role, he and McKenzie were splitting snaps there - McK averaging 47% of the snaps and Crowder 36% before breaking his leg, with the Buffalo sportswriters frantically reading "tea leaves" about who got more snaps each week. Anyway, McKenzie is the Colts problem now. Another viewpoint is that McKenzie had been stuck on the depth chart behind Beasley and had broken out for some very big games when given the chance. It's not like he'd been given a chance to start in the slot and failed previously - Beasley never wanted to leave the field, broken ribs, broken leg, didn't matter. The Bills didn't want to put their full trust in McK as a slot, thus the Crowder signing, but Crowder also had a resume of being injured and unavailable. From how they were handled in camp and their snaps early in the season, it seemed as though the Bills viewed them as competing or at least, sharing snaps.
  5. Josh said it was an ad-lib by Josh, so, there is that. It's a point that a good RB or WR (especially with Josh as their QB) needs to be on their toes and ready for anything until the whistle blows. It's why I think folks here have a valid point that McKenzie had "focus" issues. It's like he ran his reverse, didn't get the handoff, got to the sideline and said "my job here is done" instead of being ready for whatever.
  6. C'mon Simon you know that's a trick question. The correct answer is "neither of you" You hang out here. That's not normal. What you do with your underwear is a red herring. Your wife is married to you. That places her normalcy into question, right there, regardless of any dainty folding habits.
  7. I like the "giving someone some work" aspect. Our personal problem with hiring people, is the Sebastian the Crab aspect: "if you want it done right, you have to do it yourself". We try to find contractors or companies with good reviews or who have done good recent work for people we know, but it's still been a mixed bag. If there were a magic wand I could wave to ensure that the company or contractor we hire would do a competent professional job with no hassles, we'd probably hire more and do less. Part of the problem is that we're both engineers and have a lot of construction/remodeling hands-on experience and we read up to fill in the gaps, so we can really tell when something is not being done correctly.
  8. LOL Wat? Some people enjoy doing projects, like building a deck or painting it. Some people don't enjoy it, but they enjoy saving money with DIY they can then spend on other things, be it necessities or gifts or vacations But if you have enough money to meet your needs and wants, and you don't enjoy stuff like building a deck, why would you do it if you can afford to hire someone? Let another man eat, and spend your time doing something you do enjoy. Life's uncertain, and too short to pinch every penny and spend time doing stuff you don't enjoy outside work if you have alternatives.
  9. Makes perfect sense to me. I almost threw out an insulated Yeti that is perfect for my morning coffee, AND a present from my daughter to boot, because it is that exact color of Dolphins aqua. I decided the cachet of my daughter spending her (at the time) scarce and hard-earned money on a gift, far outweighed the unfortunate color, so I kept it, but I had to think about it. But then, I've been a fan from the mid-60s and can well remember 20 consecutive straight losses through the '70s
  10. Shakir played 275 snaps. That means that 205 of them were probably against zone coverage, since I doubt he was doubled up in man with Diggs and Davis on the field. Since 75% of his snaps were presumably against zone, the question for his long-term prospects would be “how well did he get open there?” I believe this stat is just measuring whether the receiver has separation at the completion of his route vs. man coverage It’s not assessing: 1) whether he ran the correct route at the correct depth 2) whether he was open at the point where the QB had to make a decision and throw the ball 3) whether there was a better throw available
  11. I don’t think a team could do that under the terms of the CBA 1) the NFL, an entertainment business, mandates media availability for players. It’s not consistent with that to limit in-season media 2) the players want to “build their brand”, gain name recognition so they can sell merch and perhaps be marketable for broadcasting gigs. They can’t say anything “detrimental to the league”, but requiring team approval would allow teams too much control of what players do on their time off. So the NFLPA would fight it.
  12. So Logic-ally, the problem with the "gadget role" niche is, if the player does not run any other plays, opposing defenses key on him and say "here comes the reverse" or "get ready, there's that jet sweep again!". We saw that towards the end of the 2019 season, and Daboll started to use McKenzie on shallow crossers and slants, just so that teams couldn't key on it. So "gadget guy" really needs to have a broader vocabulary.
  13. First of all, a lot of my post to which you're responding was in response to someone else, not to your comment "Idk why, but he’s too dam small and his arms to too dam short to be a good target." Lose the crowing about "checkmate", because I'm not trying to argue that the history of the NFL is replete with successful small short receivers - I'm making the point that if what you say is true about McKenzie, it's an ongoing problem for the Bills. (as far as NFL history, there's always a rule until someone comes along and breaks it. And Beasley, FWIW, measured 5'7 7/8" which gives him a mighty 3/8" on McKenzie) Second, it absolutely has a lot to do with Beane! If the problem with McKenzie is that he's "too damned small and his arms are too short to be a good target", then in fact the Buck stops in the middle of Beane's desk by going into the season with two options at slot: 1) Crowder, who at 5'9"( combine 5'8 3/8") is not THAT much bigger, and who had missed almost 1/3 of his games the previous two seasons 2) McKenzie, who is listed in Pro Football Reference as 5'8" (combine measurement 5'7 1/2") and who has 28 3/4" arms And it will also be on Beane that he's apparently replacing a good bit of McKenzie's role in the slot with Harty, who is listed as 5'6 3/8" and 28 1/4" arms. Please note that McKenzie was used on deep routes (from the slot) as I expect Harty will be - but do you really expect Harty to be able to line up outside and gain a clean release or hand-fight against much longer armed corners? That seems like a big "ask" to me. And if McKenzie's problem was that he's "too damned small and his arms are too short" to be a good target, isn't that just exacerbated with Harty? Personally, I don't think McKenzie's issue is that he's too small to be a good target. I think some other folks called part of it out correctly: he could lack focus within games leading to some inexplicable gaffes. And even if he is correct that he was open, his habit of body-catching the ball made him a dangerous target on some routes and didn't necessarily mean he was running the route Josh expected against that coverage (wherever the disconnect may lie). So if Harty can stay healthy, I think he can be a good target despite his short stature and arms. And yes, Beane explicitly said "we see him as our #4" meaning not as the starting slot - but he does have to be able to run a larger route tree than just gadgets, and I'm not sure he can handle the outside role you suggest at his size vs. getting a free release as a slot then running a deep route. PS short arms are also an issue with Shakir, 29", which may also hinder his use outside. Unless Shorter or Patmon or someone come thru, I think we're still thin outside, it's Diggs Davis and who?
  14. I could be wrong, but I thought he’d been a decent pass blocker in LA and the notion was Kromer would get him back to that
  15. I think there's a bit of revisionist history or at least edited history by Beane there. They clearly expected McKenzie and Crowder to compete for snaps in the slot last season. Going into the season Beane talked as though McKenzie had earned a shot at the slot role. McKenzie said he was open against zone and Josh wouldn't throw to him. I think that's true. At least in part, I think that's because Josh simply didn't trust McKenzie to 1) read the defense and run the route option Josh expected him to run as Josh expected him to run it - he could be open, but if he's open doing something different than Josh expects, as Beasley said "there will be a lot of interceptions" so Josh wouldn't take that risk 2) run the routes with the proper shape and timing 3) make it "his ball or no one's ball", especially if the throw were a bit off-target. McKenzie's biggest flaw as a receiver IMO was his persistent tendency to body-catch. As we saw in Miami with Josh's interception off Beasley, it's dangerous to try to body-catch in traffic; if the ball is deflected, it can very well be picked. I also had the impression that he had a bit of the "mule trained with loving kindness" about him, in that it took A Lot to get him to listen to feed back and make changes. Mmm, that would be why Beane paid more money to Deonte Harty, who is like an inch shorter and has slightly shorter arms? Because he's too damned short to be a good target?
  16. It will indeed be interesting to see what they get out of Harty, and yes, they paid him quite a lot of their limited FA budget (not quite twice what McK earned last season, but significantly more) Whatever folks say about McKenzie not being able to catch, the facts are he caught 64.6% of the passes listed as targeting him (2nd on the Bills team to Diggs and 15 percentage points higher than Shakir for whom folks here clamored). He was durable - missed something like 2 games due to injury in the last 3 seasons. Harty has a better catch % over his career, but he's missed something like 25 games over the last 3 seasons. So I don't know what we'll see. I've gotten "thumb down" or X'd in another thread for pointing out that Beane has a bit of a track record for spending significant $$ of a limited budget on potentially high-ceiling contributors who have not worked out - Corey Coleman, OJ Howard etc. I just hope Deonte Harty isn't this year's version. (Note that I'm not suggesting we should have kept McKenzie, who clearly wasn't able to be on the same page as Josh against zone for whatever reason)
  17. 'Fess Up, Wise Guys: which of you have been posting on The Twitters? https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/fans-are-already-blaming-hailee-steinfeld-for-distracting-josh-allen/ar-AA1c0aj6 Which of you Wise Guys posted that? But once again, I can't keep up. This article is claiming that So all you people who heard rumors of a bartender?...or maybe it was a college soccer player? Who was it? No one? Bartender? Soccer player? Actress? Then again: What I wanna know is who's the dude with Greer Gustavon?
  18. Someone had already called 911 The lifeguard was performing chest compressions initially, later a doctor took over the chest compressions. Under those circumstances, running off to look for the AED was the exact appropriate thing to do
  19. Is that what's meant by "Gay Conversion Therapy"?
  20. "Far removed from my 30s" -> you're 17 and live with your mom, amiright?
  21. I agree with you that his odds are poor and he faces an uphill fight, especially with the current trend being to hire offensive coordinators and assistants. My point was that he has faced poor odds and an uphill fight at many previous stages of his life, and nevertheless he's prevailed. I think the HC interview process depends a lot on salesmanship: how good of a plan the coach has put together and how tailored it is to the specifics of the interviewing team. So I can see where time to self-reflect and spend analyzing one's plans and maybe taking a fresh approach to them might be helpful, along with not trying to divide responsibilities between defensive game planning and interview prep.
  22. Having a different or unpopular opinion doesn't make someone a troll Making a certain style of post repetitively does though. Wait, I can't keep up. Weren't you worried that Brittany Williams was basically Amber Frey?
  23. It's his specialty. He's already critiqued JA for "dressing like he's in HS" and looking like a bum, as well as admitted he knows that cosmetics make a huge difference to a woman's appearance in photographs. And that's not even getting into his posts in other threads where he was opining that because athletes get asked about their hobbies and movies and favorite eats, it's appropriate to ask them about every detail of every aspect of their personal lives. 🙄 He may at some point have something useful or interesting to say about football At present he's behaving like a troll-y troll and would be better left alone under his bridge.
  24. https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.02.0002
  25. I imagine one could probably find some errant passes at the Bills practice did the press choose to show them. We know Baker can complete 60% of his passes at the NFL level.
×
×
  • Create New...