-
Posts
13,659 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Recent Profile Visitors
12,033 profile views
Beck Water's Achievements

All Pro (7/8)
11.4k
Reputation
-
Jags release Christian Kirk, seems like a Billsy move
Beck Water replied to Roundybout's topic in The Stadium Wall
Did I miss something? Did we re-sign Hollins or is he a FA? -
Ask your doctor if a prescription for Zofran is right for you This is basically it. I'm trying to think what talking head it was - maybe Emmanuel Acho? said that winning teams need to have about 3 "Freakazoids" each on offense and defense - impact players who can take over and turn the game. The Bills have Josh Allen, who is a Super Freakazoid. Then they have some quality NFL players on both sides of the ball. But as far as Freakazoids, Nah. We need more.
-
Stafford given permission to seek trade
Beck Water replied to Kirby Jackson's topic in The Stadium Wall
I understood the Carr thing. I don't mean it made sense, but I understood it. Josh McDaniels did a similar thing in Denver: he shipped Jay Cutler out of town in favor of Kyle Orton (I don't mean the players are the same, but it's the same theme: Mr Big Stuff doesn't want to adapt to the players he has, he wants his own guys.) But McVay traded for Stafford and won a Superbowl with him. So.... -
Stafford given permission to seek trade
Beck Water replied to Kirby Jackson's topic in The Stadium Wall
Kirk Cousins IMO is a big step down from Stafford. -
Stafford given permission to seek trade
Beck Water replied to Kirby Jackson's topic in The Stadium Wall
Kelly Stafford is "a lot" but let's be real... Stafford is going to be 37 next year, and the ROI the Rams have gotten from him since the Superbowl have been "meh". It's not that he's played badly - not at all - but the year they won the Superbowl, he passed for 41 TDs and 287 ypg. Doesn't look as though he's gonna return to that performance. If Stafford were still lighting it up, his wife could be yattering on Social Media all she wants I played a bit with Spotrac and I think the Rams only save about $4M if they trade Stafford. -
It's an interesting thought. On the one hand, Cook and his agent may know Beane puts extensions 4th in priority, so they're throwing down "this is what we expect as a portion, better leave that room under the cap for us when you start cooking up extensions" On the other hand, you're right - this does give Beane the chance to maybe put a higher priority on Ty Johnson, maybe make different FA and draft moves You just might be right that if he'd waited until after the draft, Beane might be thinking "k, got RB locked down" and wind up with fewer options
-
I don't think the Bills much care for it either. They've previously made clear they don't want to negotiate contracts in public. Beane would extend Cook for the same reason he's extended other players with a year remaining on their contracts: -players really don't like to play on a 1 year contract because nothing is guaranteed if they get hurt, so the team has a bit more leverage -the team can talk up getting new money up front/guarantees while the player has the choice "play for us on a 1 year, or take a new contract that might be less than the open market would give you IF you don't get hurt and IF you have another great year Beane will definitely prioritize negotiating with any of the team's FA he wants to re-up, then negotiating with FA, then the draft, before he tries to extend guys who are currently under contract. As far as how he prioritizes extensions, arguably Cook is the one with the most notable stats across the league. Of the RBs who are top-20 for attempts, he is 16th for yards (reflecting his lower number of attempts, but 5th for Y/A and tied for 1st in TDs. I personally feel that Shakir is the least replaceable player simply because of how reliable his hands are and how little else the Bills have at WR, but as a receiver his stats aren't that remarkable. I'm not sure, but I think if the Bills want the best pass-protecting RB or the best route-running, receiving RB, Cook is neither - so it's bench time.
-
I don't think Cook is bad for asking for it. But I think he's asking for more than the market. It causes problems when you pay one player well over market. You get other players who aren't FA looking over at him going "OK, what about me?" What was it the Bills coaches used to tell guys "watch who gets paid"? No one would object to Cook getting a market-value extension early, or even a high market value extension. Way over market value? Eh. As @BarleyNY pointed out, $15M a year would make him the 2nd highest paid RB. It's a point worth noting that the highest paid RB, Christian McCaffrey, is a total game changer and elite weapon in the run and in the pass game - and that his team has not received the desired ROI, as he played in only 4 games last season.
-
Call the repairman! Posted because You Are Enough(tm) and I care!