Chaos

If the roster is better every year for five years and the coaching is fine why are the results not better year over year?

The entire dline disappeared against the Chiefs in the playoffs. Its honestly hard for me to imagine anyone of them (including Oliver) are of critical strategic importance to the teams playoff success.

When did they get old? Just since last season? Why didn't Beane know about the teaching younger faster players strategy before this off season?

I think you are confusing with "what i will consider successful" with "what I actually expect"

"When" includes forever. This is a fairly clever expectation setting question. Literally impossible to fall short of, unless the NFL or Bills go out of business before forever. Center and guard positions are both changing. I though McGovern was a good guard. But he is not a known factor at Center. By the way I agree with cutting Morse.

My personal opinion is that all sports franchise gms and coaches spend a considerable amount of effort to manage expectations. Thier key to personal success is not winning championships, the key to success is beating expectations. The lower one can set the expecations, the more likely one is to succeed. Another personal opinion is that the Bills organization is masterful at managing expectations. One pillar of that strategy is "we were so awful in the past, that any appearance of competence oughta be satisfactory to the fans in the cheap seat". Fans love activity in the offseason. We have been treated to a lot of activity this week. The consensus opinion about every decision seems to be "this is great" and "this had to be done". So I polling at this point, what does it all mean for 2024?

Does therir Super Bowl have an asterisk?

Beane is iike a double wizard. He was declared a wizard for signing Harty, and is declared a wizard for releasing Harty the following year. Double wizards are tough to find.

Do coordinators Brady or Babich have any influence over today's decisions?

lunancy

You expect Allen to take a pay cut?

I am an offense first guy. However the big 3 money positions are QB, WR, Edge Rusher. You can't have too many good WRs with favorable contracts. You can't have too many edge rushers with favorable contracts. Sutton is very good WR. If there was a way to afford him, and allow us to add a young edge rusher in the first round rather than WR, that would be perfectly fine. There is a LOT of room on the upside on the edge for the Bills.

In any given year about 28 NFL fan bases think the off season moves made the team better. A couple of fan bases will understand they are tearing down to rebuild. Sometime the Super Bowl winner will run into a cap wall and has no where to go but down (Rams a few years back) But since the 2024 Bills won’t be playing the 2023 Bills it is not really the important question. The important roster question is “Will the Bills roster be relatively better than the Chiefs/Bengals/Ravens/Titans rosters ?”

Its a cap move. too much cap hit for a backup.

don’t worry. We will win the off season. It is the most certain lock in all of sports.

He spent a year on the practice squad and no one poached him for his high school results.

The Bills have quite a few more players in the 3 to 10’milion cap hit range than the chiefs do. I am curious as to how much more production you get from Ryan Bates at 5.4 million. Compared to say Ryan Van Demark at 0.9 million.

Why would people expect Shorter to be better than the practice squad wide receivers on the 31 other teams? It seems to me there is a large pool of similar talent.

Its all relative. Main competetion, Chiefs, Bengals, Ravens are all in better cap shape.

How do you measure a drafts success without hindsight? Seems most people insist you need wait five years to see how a draft actually went.

This sums things up in three words. If your happy with pretty darn good, you are happy. If pretty darn good is not what you are looking for from coaching staff then you are not happy. The McDermott quote reminded me of this guy:

Not only unpopular by also ridiculous.

This falls more into the category of prediction than opinion ( I suppose predictions by thier nature are opinions). And I am sure it will be unpopular. The Bills offense will excel in 2024 The defense will struggle. Bills fans will apologize for the struggles by pointing out the problems which are obvious today White, Milano and Miller will all play like former stars attempting to recover from major injuries, but not returning close to form The safety position will struggle, because the combined ages of this years two starts is approaching 70. The edge rusher position will be NFL average The interior defense will be NFL average linebackers will be below NFL average Cornerbacks will be NFL average Defensive struggles will be blamed on the new DC Babich. Defensive struggles will be apologized for by fans due to cap limitations special teams will be as as bad as 2023 Due to Josh Allen and the offense, the team will make the playoffs Some players will be injured Some games will be impacted by bad calls Bills will go out in the divisional round of the playoffs. Fans will generally conclude, the Bills did not advance further because of things beyond the Bills control. After the season TBD posters will argue about whether significant changes should be made No significant changes will be made. I will be happy to be wrong and watch the Bills hoist the Lombardi If the Bills hoist the Lombardi, someone will revive this thread and poop on this post. This will also make me happy.

Do you think Knox is going to simply take less money without getting cut and becoming a free agent? Or do you think the bills will restructure and guarantee the rest of his contract.

Why do you think the Bills would want to restructure?