Chaos

One is a guy who is rich and can cook. one is a guy who is rich and won’t let you eat bread. it’s not clear to me which one women really want.

If the Bills organization does not trust him with the head coaching decison, he can’t be considered a top GM, only a top player personnel manager. The top GMs are given control over the organization.

The poll choices are overly limited. A - (He’s consistently put us in a position to win with Super Bowl-capable rosters while skillfully finessing the cap). I would propose a fix A - He’s consistently put us in a position to win with Super Bowl-capable rosters and coaching staffs B+ He’s consistently put us in a position to win with Super Bowl-capable rosters, but there is not evidence the coaching staffs are capable of a deep playoff run I can't give an A in the current poll, because it ignores one of the critical elements of team building, coaching.

This thread is facinating.

The title clearly says “collection of talent” not “team”.

I am excited we have DC who has mentor to guide him.

is Beane somehow obligated to pursue strategies followed by a different organization more than seven years ago? Or can he be expected by fans to adapt and improve?

I think the concern is that the Bills have shown no propensity to develop WRs despite having an all-world qb. It is not really about Gabe Davis. Personally I do not care about how the offense gets it done. They have been a top five offense for years now. Whatever blocks the bills from going further in the playoffs it’s not been the offense.

I took the original post to imply everyone else sucked

Confused, does this make you blind or unable to talk?

Not wild about Babich's "mentor upstairs comment". Never really heard a coordinator say something like that before. Seems weak.

Yes. keyword = lost. In the context of the Patriots winnig six super bowls without him.

Coulda shoulda woulda. One of the few patriots who never won a Super Bowl with Brady. Literally a non-factor for ever winning a championship.

Nice post. "Dorsey's demise was not utilizing Allen as a runner in the first 10 games of 2023". Should be bolded for emphasis. Not clear based on preseason comments last year that this was Dorsey's decision. The real question is how to not end the playoffs 1-1, or 0-1. I wish I had the answer. But it does not seem to be an issue with offensive talent. Or even offensive execution. To my eyes, the Bills have been out gameplanned in the playoff games. And the defense has faltered to many times in key moments.

The point of thread has nothing to do with a claim we need to add a hall of fame tight end. The point is the WR room is fine as is. And people's dreaming of adding some elusive WR that is the difference between winning the super bowl and not is silly. And also statistically not likely.

Ward was a great player. No question about it. Not a single thread post I have seen clamoring for improving the WR room, has indicated that we need a Hines Ward type though. Its clear you are being intentionally obtuse. Get a life.

Not sure you get the point. But if I am going pine for something as a fan, the evidence would indicate we should want a HOF TE rather than adding another WR. Also maybe Kincaid can become that guy.

About 50% of Super Bowls won this Century, had Rob Gronwkowski, Travis Kelce, Jimmy Graham or Hines Ward as the leading pass catcher on the winning team. Winning Super Bowls without a Calvin Johnson or Justin Jefferson level WR1 is not just possible, its actually more common than not. Notwithstand the frequent turnover in OC's, the pre-2023 nightmare of an oline, the Bills offense has performed at level consistent with winning a Super Bowl for the last five years. Its just silly to think the Bills current WR room is going to hold the Bills back. Stefon Diggs was my favorite Bill other than Allen, since Diggs joined the team. I will miss rooting for him. But the Bills are not going to miss a beat on offense without him. Josh Allen will just get things done in a different way. The Bills ability to get over the hump in the playoffs lies elswere. It has had very little to do with the talent on the offensive roster.

At this point Burrows has to have an asterisk that says “for seasons he plays in” Jujitsu notwithstanding, I expect every GM sees Tua as a substantially above average injury risk.

Your post is ironic. I suspect unintentionally ironic.

My impression was Diggs issues with Buffalo was with coaching compentency in the playoffs hurting the chance to win. ( I am not saying is or isn't right, but I that is my impression of Diggs problem). I think he will play hard this year and see how far the Texans can go. And his happiness and next steps will depend on that.

Anything is possible. But I will be disappointed if he does not develop until Allen’s ninth year

Athe difference in Collin’s third season has a name : CJ Stroud. Coleman starts with Allen. If he is not a good WR by the middle of the upcoming season, he likely will never be too tier.

Was any WR ever added to the roster for the purpose of improving the WR room?

Punting is giving the ball away.