Chaos

We lost to a Zach Wilson jet team. Your comment clearly indicates you are confused

Philosophy is often personnel dependent. The Bills will fully utilize Kincaid.

Because PFF had a separate post giving out A+ grades

No. Mahomes was a consenus first round pick. Ajdusting for positional value, he was a bit of a reach at 10. But he is far from the biggest reach to succeed.

Not really. Most every players has someone criticizing. PFF and Football Outsiders both proclaimed it a great pick. Hurts was exected to be a third round pick, he went at 53 overall. He certainly has out performed his draft position. But that is not what the thread is about. Hurts does not really qualify as a reach. https://www.pff.com/news/draft-jalen-hurts-wasnt-a-good-pick-by-the-philadelphia-eagles-he-was-a-great-one

Being skepitcal of a pick succeeding has nothing at all to do with being a reach. I am skeptical Bryce Young (too small) CJ Stroud (poor cognitive test results, Ohio State QB), or Anthony Richardson (poor college production) will succeed in the NFL. However none of them were a draft reach. Their draft position aligned with the public consensus fairly closely.

4.55 to 4.45 is a pretty huge difference. That would be a different category of talent to project. I have a theory that is he is a victim of over training. And that if the Bills conditioners can "loosen him up" a bit, the agility may be improvabile.

His like of agility makes him an outlier.

Only onside kicks actually create an exta possession. Otherwise possessions simply alternate. Each drive has four ways to end, a score, turnovers, turnvover on downs, or a punt.

I think you under consider how bad Zack Wilson was. The gap last season from Allen to Rodgers is about the same size as the gap last season from Rodgers to Wilson. Unless Rodgers does a Russell Wilson imitation, it is a huge upgrade.

I am hoping some of the people who think the Aaron Rodgers led Jets are not "far better" than the Zach Wilson led Jets can provide some color on their thinking.

Both are good, and they will be comped against each other in the future. I think Kindcaid's more WR similarities makes him a better fit for the Bills than Mayer though.

Good question Another one is, "did the defense focus on shutting him down and take him away, allowing the Utah team to compete and almost beat a gold standard SEC team?"

A lot of people view Gibbs as more than an RB. Niners are no longer criticized for trading for McCafferty. I suspect the lions are hoping for something along those lines.

I think you need to actually watch the games to know why he was not being targeted. I actually am typically interested in who teams turn too when they are losing in the second half. If a team is winning and running the ball, no particular reason to be passing to anyone.

me either, hence the question.

I know he was not a fan favorite when drafted. Where was he projected to be drafted to make him a reach?

Broeker may be competition for Spencer Brown.

I promise two guys besides Milano will be starters.

Interesting one. If he had been a 4th round draft pick, his NFL statistics would look very good. But he has a tremendously long career and is 10th in points for a career. So I think he qualifies as going on to success. And he was definitely considered a reach.

Whitner was a reach who went on to great success in the NFL?

All five of those guys will play games in the NFL.

It fits the general concept of going against the grain, and making a bold decision. Taking a guy at 1 instead of 5 is probably equalivalent to taking a guy at 25 instead of 100.

Good b Good observation. Good thread.