The playoff structure is broken. Having the #1 seed be the only bye, and having the advantage of re-bracketing the playoffs after each round is too big of an advantage in a league with unbalanced schedules.
But that is the rule.
And Andy Reid clearly grasps that the week 1 game counts as much as the week 15 game, and is prepared and grinds every game. McDermott did a fine job getting to 12-3. But McDermott's attention to every detail (going back to 13 seconds) is a cut below the Chiefs, and this coaching difference is arguably the primary reason the Chiefs are the #1 seed, and Bills are not, despite having beaten the Chiefs.
The Bills have a legit shot at the Super Bowl this year. The #1 seed advantages give the Chiefs a better shot. But all the teams are flawed, including the Chiefs,and the Bills chances are second best in the NFL (in my opinion). If Bills win the Super Bowl, the decision to ride with McDermott (currently only Tomlin, Harbaugh and Reid are longer tenured with their team) for as long as they have will be validated.
If the Bills don't advance to the Super Bowl, the offseason threads will be dominated by two themes.
1. One group of fans insisting that the Bills 2024 season was a coaching miracle of taking a bunch of injured misfits to the playoffs (backed by the ridiculous pre-season narratives that the Jets and Dolphins were far better positioned to win the AFC East)
2. Another group of fans asking "Is eight seasons enough time for a head coach with a potential Hall of Fame QB on the roster a fair chance to get to the Super Bowl?"
Both groups of posters will be 100% sure there is no possible legimate point of view expressed by the posters in the opposing group.