Yeah, nobody will be saying Garrett is too expensive if we win the Super Bowl, possibly if we even just make it. At a certain point the numbers and "next year" simply don't matter. The way things are looking right now, we likely shouldn't be worse than the 3 seed, and it's possible we somehow get even higher than that.
When that's the situation you're looking at and how close we've been in recent years, I simply don't know why we wouldn't sell the house to absolutely maximize our talent.