FireChans

Why are you so down on Herby?

Dodson doesn’t wear the green dot lol. They even made a point of it because Klein exited the game when he got hurt and they had to switch helmets. This is what I’m talking about with the criticisms. We should have guys like Dorian Williams and Tyrel Dodson (who have no experience organizing the defense) do it because we know the defense looked bad otherwise. Its nonsense.

They didn’t make the playoffs for 17 years prior with a broken team culture. You may have missed that.

McD made the playoffs with Tyrod Taylor at QB and Kelvin Benjamin at WR1.

Tua and the Brocketship over Herbert is INSANE.

I disagree. While Burrow has been injured twice in his career, he has shown at his peak the ability to beat Mahomes in Arrowhead and go to the Super Bowl. Stroud played at a very high level but for only 1 year, and lost to the weight class above him. If I made this list last year, Hurts was rounding out the top 5, now he’s almost on the edge. That matters as well.

My top 10 QB ranking historically has been “if every QB was a free agent tomorrow, what would their contracts rank,” because it takes into account injury risk, youth and ceiling. Mahomes Allen Burrow Jackson Stroud Herbert Love Dak Lawrence Hurts On the bubble was Cousins, Stafford, Goff, Rodgers for the criterion listed above. I’m starting to lose faith in Hurts but until he crashes and burns I can’t keep him out.

Target share of rookie WR/Diggs/Kincaid/Shakir in no particular order is my vote.

As much crap as Josh or the coaching has gotten for not being good enough in our last games of the season, the DL is sneaky biggest no show crew. They did nothing in a game where we NEEDED the front four to help cover the back 7. And last year, the entire front 7 all got blown off the ball against the Bengals who were playing a couple backups that game. I think the only one who made any kind of a play last year was Milano. Thuney is the best OG for a reason and the strength of the KC line is their interior. But stars who are paid like stars are supposed to make star plays in big moments. For Ed to basically not win a rep and Rousseau and Floyd to no show vs the shaky OT’s is unacceptable.

Thad Lewis should just play that video of him getting lit up while delivering a strike to Stevie Johnson to beat the Dolphins and not elaborate.

Folks don’t understand that if Josh and the Bills break through once, whether Mahomes gets hurt or they beat them once in the postseason and the Bills win the whole thing, it will be all the more meaningful after this. No SB team was built in a day.

He was the reigning MVP, finished the game with 162 passing yards, 34 rushing yards, 1 pick and 3 sacks. Come on man.

Yeah yeah, and if Dorian Williams gets spun around on misdirection on runs like he has ALL SEASON, and Pacheco had 120 yards at half, you’d be playing Monday morning coordinator questioning the decision to put him out there when Klein led the team in tackles the week before. Dorian doesn’t even have experience with the green dot, you think he should be QBing the defense in that spot? ”anything would have been better” is not a sufficient answer. And honestly, I don’t think it’s true.

Shutting down the reigning MVP Lamar Jackson to clinch the first Bills AFCCG appearance since the 1993 season. Defensive masterclass.

If anyone has ever played Madden, you know you can’t score there. I thought Josh was a Madden guy.

I don’t understand this argument that our base nickel D was getting run on, but we want less linebackers in coverage. I guess you wanted to start out with more dime looks? Or you wanted Matakevich out there in coverage? Neither of those sound like solutions to me. To me, the one of the biggest injuries prior to this game was Rapp. I think this game needed our big nickel 3 safety look that we had been going with occasionally. But we couldn’t, because everyone was hurt.

Can you tell me our W/L record in games Josh has multiple TO’s?

Allen had a pretty good OL in 2020 and 2023, yeah. In 2021 and 2022 there was some regression and poor OL play that Allen was covering for. You know who has had really spotty OT play all year? Mahomes. Our OL on average was probably a little better than his this year. Our weapons on average were better than his this year. We still lost. He still outplayed Allen. That’s why this one hurt the most.

Torrence was a day 2 pick. Dawkins was a day 2 pick. Knox was a day 2 pick. Zay Jones was a day 2 pick. Spencer Brown was a day 2 pick. This is a total flail job because Justin Shorter didn’t play in our playoff game.

Prior to this season, Diggs was a top 5 WR. For all the big games Allen wins in January, he wears every divisional loss as well.

BB to Buffalo is intriguing, especially as we are going to need a defensive overhaul anyway. Biggest roadblock, imo, is that there’s some kind of handshake deal with Kraft and BB that he doesn’t go in the division.

McD has played younger players his whole career if they are good. If they suck, they don’t play. Benford played a lot last year. Elam did not. Zay Jones played a lot when he was a rookie (he sucked, but sucked less than everyone else). Dorian Williams is spinning like a top out there on defense, so he doesn’t play. Shakir struggled with drops, so he didn’t play much as a rookie. Dawkins played every game as a rookie, because he was good. Tre White played every game as a rookie, because he was good. Rousseau played almost every game as a rookie, because he was good. Honestly, this is such a tired narrative. Yes, Boogie Basham didn’t see the field a lot, it’s because he ***** sucks.

Are we positive Allen is “on that level” of a multiple MVP, multiple SB MVP winner?

That’s fine. Mahomes in 2018 was a way better QB than Allen in 2018. He had better coaching, better weapons, and was the better player. These things can all be true.

It mattered because every game mattered until the playoffs started. For all we know, an extra week of rest helps the entire team show up vs the Chiefs. I agree they should have got DHOP as well.