Not even CLOSE to the same situation. Barkley carried that offense and they didn’t have a QB. Cook hasn’t had to carry anything but the ball, when it’s his turn in the rotation. He’s good, very good, but to mistake him as the guy that carries an O is silly. The threat of Allen doesn’t let teams key on him, it’s the same reason Henry and Jackson are having a great year, you can’t stop both at once. Difference is, take away Cook and you just plug in the next guy, take away Allen and the team collapses.