SirAndrew
Community Member-
Posts
5,772 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by SirAndrew
-
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 2nd Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Coleman on a screen isn’t where I want to go on third and long. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 2nd Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Coleman needs those plays. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 2nd Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Brady’s passing game might be the most inept modern professional passing design I’ve seen. It’s weird how little this is mentioned. Allen keeps willing us to victory with a low level college passing scheme. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 2nd Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Joe Buck might be my least favorite announcer. Know it all vibe and annoying voice. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 2nd Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Thought we’d see more of that from Samuel this season. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 1st Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Joe Buck desperately wants to praise Rodgers. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 1st Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Sweet random view of the Jersey turnpike from ESPN. -
10/14/24 Game 6 Bills at (NJ) Jets MNF 1st Half Game thread
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
Rodgers is going to have a meltdown if his O line keeps this up. Dude has already been retired mentally for the past four seasons imo. -
Lincoln Riley’s clock management against Penn State was something else. The average college football coach knows a lot more about football than I, but why do so few of these guys have any concept of the clock? It’s maddening to watch.
-
Dawson Knox: 3 receptions in 5 games. $8.5M salary.
SirAndrew replied to Einstein's topic in The Stadium Wall
It doesn’t seem like it should be so difficult, especially when you have major question marks at the receiver position. Was it ever directly stated that was the plan? I like the idea, but I’m just curious if it was mentioned by the team. I thought the Kincaid choice was just a best player available decision, and we’ll worry about Knox later. -
This might be a sign of me getting old, but Bishop doesn’t even look like a guy who could be a successful NFL safety.
-
Why does no one ever mention the defense on the final Texans drive? That was also an epic McD fail imo. We should have played an aggressive normal defensive. Instead, we go into a soft prevent defense to defend against deep throws down field. There was zero pass rush, everyone played well off the line, but the Texans only needed a few yards to get into field goal range. It wouldn’t have mattered if they completed a deep pass, or an eight yard pass. We needed to stop them, but McD assumes anything longer than a 40 yard field goal attempt is some type of victory for us.
-
How was Josh able to finish the game with a concussion?
SirAndrew replied to JakeFrommStateFarm's topic in The Stadium Wall
I can’t say with certainty that Josh had a concussion, but it doesn’t seem like everyone understands. Concussions don’t necessarily mean you completely lose the ability to function mentally for an extended period of time. Not all concussions are the same, and not every person is the same. -
How was Josh able to finish the game with a concussion?
SirAndrew replied to JakeFrommStateFarm's topic in The Stadium Wall
Bills staff offered Josh smelling salts before he went back into the game, not sure how that would help with a chest injury. I’m surprised how many take this independent neurologist thing seriously. The league wants their stars in the game. You think they’d take Mahomes out of a Super Bowl for a concussion? Give me a break, it isn’t happening. -
Belichick or McDermott. Who's the better coach?
SirAndrew replied to Returntoglory's topic in The Stadium Wall
He’s the GOAT, but the game has passed him by. and he wouldn’t be able to connect with players as a leader at this point. -
10/6/2024 - Bills at Texans post game thread.
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
I still think this is the offense McD wants because it runs the clock to preserve the defense. I agree, it’s ridiculous, it negates your best player. -
10/6/2024 - Bills at Texans post game thread.
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
I think any decent defense can figure out a running/short passing scheme that’s very predictable. Allen running and the defensive dominating made Brady look good last year. -
10/6/2024 - Bills at Texans 1st half game thread.
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
I’m not writing him off, I just think there’s nothing in his college career that indicates he’ll be a sure number one receiver. I see him as a potential complementary piece, not a number one. I think many people are assuming he’ll become a number one. -
10/6/2024 - Bills at Texans 1st half game thread.
SirAndrew replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
I think people have always hoped for Keon to become a player that he was unlikely to ever be. -
It will be interesting to see how Kalen DeBoer responds to this Bama loss. I’ve never been sold on him being a smart coach. Dude almost gave away a Washington win in the playoffs by not knowing to take a knee. Those type of things matter at Bama. The SEC has a thin margin of error.
-
I agree, but I could see Miami/Cal being a decent game. It wouldn’t shock me to see Miami lose, or win by a thin margin. I think Miami is overrated as usual. Cam Ward has been great, and he’s the main reason Miami is improved, but I don’t trust Miami to win when the QB has a week where he isn’t spectacular.
-
I agree, I’m just saying, everyone likes to mock McDaniels for not commanding respect, but you have Reid running a team that’s out of control in their behavior. It’s his ability as an OC that makes them win games.
-
Travis Kelce shoved Reid on the sideline. That doesn’t seem like an old school leader who demands respect.
-
You’re probably correct in a lot of this, but I don’t think the average fan can assess leadership ability from sideline television images. The most important leadership happens behind closed doors. He might be a terrible leader, but I don’t know it’s that easy to say.
-
I think people want the Vince Lombardi speeches, but today’s game is more about X’s and O’s. McDaniel is good at that part of the game, and he’s now coaching a backup QB. Teams don’t usually win with a backup. That’s not solely on the coach. I don’t think he’s great, but I think the leadership/pep talk stuff is overrated. This generation of players isn’t going to respond to Kneut Rockne speeches. It’s more about players liking their head coach, avoiding a toxic environment. It seems that team likes McDaniel plenty well enough.