Ethan in Cleveland

Oh hell yes they have wasted money. But you didn't post about waste. You posted about not spending and investing resources on impact players. Because it did not work out is not the same as they did not try. I 100% agree on OT and firmly believe if White had not gotten injured they would have drafted WR or OT in 2022. For the millionth time, Kincaid is not a TE. He is a slot WR the same as Aaron Hernandez was for New England. He will never ever line up where Knox lines up. And when he comes up for a contract extension/tag he will argue it should be as a hybrid WR/TE as others have argued based on percentage of plays he is flexed out in a two point stance.

Yes but as the other poster noted, Bills were down 2 of 4 starters on the DL and we have no idea how healthy Rousseau's foot/ankle was down the stretch. Still I think most of us saw this as an advantage and yet again Oliver (1 tackle), Epenesa(1 tackle), and Basham(zero tackles) failed to step up.

Rex was fine for in game HC decisions. His downfall was the NFL figured out his defense. Rex may have been a fine HC if he had just kept Schwartz and let him run that amazing defense. Rex built a top 5 scoring offense with a powerhouse run game. He just could not keep his and his dumb brother's ego out of the way of a perfectly fine defense. McD as a DC is far superior to Rex. As a leader they both have good qualities. I would take McD's style over Rex's but I also think Rex would have managed the Hamlin situation just as well. He bonded well with the players. He showed empathy.

Obviously I'm not a huge McD fan, but his challenges got better in 2022 I thought. His time management in games especially before the half is excellent. I agree he wastes TO's on defense. His defenses seem to give up too many long 3rd downs but if you look at the stats they are still really good on 3rd down. I would add his ability to create a short yardage package is really lacking. Bills offense has really struggles on 3rd and short situations. McDermott can't even win playoff games. Harbaugh has better playoff record and has taken his team to the SB. I will take a Lombardi even if he is a douchebag. FYI, actually met him once on a street in Amsterdam with his wife. He was very personable and chatted with me and my wife for 20 min or so while they waited for a car to take them to dinner.

So far yes. And I agree the loss to TCU was embarrassing especially after what they did to OSU. No excuses for that loss. Of course he has an NFC Championship win. What is McD biggest win? Division round against the Ravens?

Awful? Based on what criteria?

They spent money on Miller last year and in years past Morse. They have extended Allen, White, Diggs, Knox, Hyde, Poyer, Bass, Oliver, and Milano. They have invested a first round pick in Rousseau. I'd have no argument if you said Oliver, Knox, and a couple others are not impact players. They have extended/invested money in QB, Pass rusher, WR, TE, CB, DT, and PK. Outside of the OT spots where else would you have them spend money?

Stay healthy for the playoffs and hope McD doesn't prevent Allen from taking us all the way. Allen needs to throw 3 less INTs Knox needs 20 more receptions Davis needs 6 less drops Find a suitable RT and establish O'Cyrus a day 1 starter in training camp. Bills D needs to play a deep shell most of the year. Keep everything in front of them and force the opponent to dink and dunk. Save the pass rush for the playoffs. Keep Von Miller and Leonard Floyd fresh for January. Let Epenesa and Basham burn calories chasing the QBs in Sept and Oct.

Off the top of my head I would have thought Mario Williams, Tre White, and Lee Evans would be on this list. Evans in 2006 had 82 catches for nearly 1300 yards, 8 TDs, and a 15.8 YPC. Williams in 2013 had 13 sacks and followed it up in 2014 with 14.5 sacks. White made All-Pro in 2019 and had 6 picks with a ridiculous QB rating against of less than 40 for the entire season. Byrd was good but this season by White was superior.

He won the Orange Bowl at Stanford when he had Luck. He's never had a QB like Allen at Michigan or San Francisco. He beat Green Bay and Rodgers on the road in the playoffs. McD has yet to win a single road playoff game. And nobody ever accused his teams of being soft.

If Bills miss the playoffs in 2023, I would replace McD with Jim Harbaugh in 2024. He was 44-19-1 (0.695)in regular season and 5-3(0.625) in post season. Both those records compare favorably to McD at 0.639 and 0.444. Assuming that will not happen then McD will be back for 2024. If no SuperBowl in 23 or 24 I would fire him no matter the circumstances. I would then target either Harbaugh or Lincoln Riley. There may be other option available by then too. However Allen is going to make all this get rid of McD talk silly. Because Allen is going to will this team to a SB this year despite McD just like Manning did with Dungy.

Can you define true #2? Separating in small spaces has little to do with an outside WR. That is what your slot WR does. I really don't think this board understands the Bills offense at all. Davis is an excellent WR who had too many drops last year. Had he made a few more catches he would have had elite numbers as an outside deep threat. And this was with an injured ankle. I also have to believe if Davis made that catch against the Jets on the desperation bomb at the end of the game this entire discussion would be different.

McVay didn't have the QB talent McD does McD doesn't have a SB appearance. Neither did Dungy before he was replaced in Tampa. If McD had made a SB appearance by now there would be less than 2% of people wanting a change. We are fans but we aren't that crazy. And where have they come since 2020? 2020 was a AFC Championship loss, 2021 was a dominant home WC round win and a Division round loss due to coaching error, and 2022 was a barely escaped with a WC win against a third string QB and RB and an embarrassing Division loss at home. Not sure how you see that as coming a long way. At best it is treading water at worst it's trending down.

Billy Martin was the Yankees Lou Saban

Wish just one coach would come out and say this whole OTA thing is bull####. Allen said it in the PC. Should only be mandatory for rookies and optional for new free agents.

Sure it is. Maybe it wasnt. Maybe it was frustration. If he was trying to send a message to Diggs it backfired horribly But I will give him the benefit of the doubt on intent and instead K think it was just a poorly executed choice of words. Words matter but can't believe it will undo their entire relationship . Yet think again who was last man standing on the field after 13 seconds. And who showed the same level of frustration we had as fans in the Detroit game. Who knows what was /is going on in Diggs mind.....

If I had to speculate, Diggs has an issue with the coaching staff. Perhaps it is with Dorsey or the fact the WR coach got scapegoated. Either way seems like he wasn't satisfied with what McD was saying yesterday. Maybe Diggs challenged McDs authority and they needed some time to cool down. Win game 1 and none of this matters.

His agent was right. Mcd made it worse. Diggs should have just practiced not trying to argue that. But obviously there is more to the story and McD made it worse.

Our long national nightmare is over

Not buy into the hype last year? Did you forsee all the injuries and a guy dying on the field? Did you post your concerns about the OL before the season started? If so kudos to you. The OL was quite good the last 6 games or so and playoffs of 2021. That coincided with Bates starting at G and Dawson recovering from COVID #2. I agree the reaction to signing Saffold was mixed on here. But in general most agreed with matching Bates contract offer. All that said, I had the same thought after his little hissy fit in the box too.

Dam. I try to be a rule follower but I missed the last sentence. If they must be active then I'm going with Doug Pederson. This guy won a SuperBowl with one of the least talented QBs. What did Reid and Belichick do without Mahommes and Brady. Yes both are excellent coaches but Pederson did more with less. And Pederson tore up BB's defense.

Zero playoff wins, 1 playoff loss, and two seasons of no playoffs is gold?

We will know a lot more after this year. We don't know the play calls and what Allen should be doing in every given play. But we could all tell from starting with the second half of the Green Bay game to the end of the season the offense just never seemed in sync or smooth. Whatever you want to call it, something didn't feel right. But yet as you pointed out statistically the numbers were fine. It just felt that yards were hard to come by and scheming guys open for easy completions was absent. As you pointed out there were too many deep shots when they needed more move the chains underneath throws. Yet they started well. So was that teams figuring out Dorsey, was that the elbow, was that bad o-line play? Probably all of the above.

Bill Walsh

Does that mean we have to lose to the Browns this year before going back to the SuperBowl? I don't think I could handle that again.