Just watched the play in question. It was a great call and with a good throw there, it is a walk in TD.
We criticize coaches for being bad all the time but in this instance it is all on the players. That is a throw any HS QB can make. It doesn't require any extraordinary physical skill. It was a horrible pass. Could it have been caught - yes. Should it have been caught - yes as well. I dont care if this guy was a PS RB. That is not that hard a catch to make.
Just awful execution by two marginal NFL players. Cut short an entire team's season by not being able to execute a simple 2 yard pass.