Elite to me means: in the conversation as best at their position (for the time period they play in), potential hall of farmer, all-pro considerations.
Josh meets that criteria obviously, not sure any other player on the roster does.
Dawkins best attribute is availability. he’s a good/very good player that is always on the field. Need players like him on the roster and glad to have him but don’t think he’s elite.
Cook was impressive this season, but I’m not ready to call him elite. He will need to string a few seasons together to make the jump. Quietist 16 touchdown season ever.
Taron Johnson is good at what he does but being the best nickel corner is like being the best slot receiver. There’s a reason you’re in that position to begin with.
Benford could be elite I guess, I have no idea. The only time I hear anything about him is on here. I’m not being flippant, I have no idea. When I think of best corner, zone coverage isn’t what I’m picturing.
no one else on the roster is a serious candidate.