No_Matter_What

Good decision. EDIT: Cmon McD.

LOL thanks Broncos.

Great Tre. Now try something here, if Josh feels fine.

Omg decline it.

Hahaha. Amazing that there was no flag. Good job guys.

That was really close.

Very nice drive overall.

Lots of fun with Josh

Did he just pronounce Risner the way it should be pronounced?

Most likely it is just a typo. Should be 11 or something.

We didn't get any help today (Jags, Bengals, Eagles). But we did our job and that matters most. Edit: Ravens probably helped us a little.

Once again we are huge Cincy fans. NYtimes says there is 6% differential in Bills playoff chances depending on their result.

Never seen a game with zero timeouts by both teams with 3:35 remaining.

This is actually a good time for White to make a mistake.

ATM it is hard to believe that Johnson wouldn't be an upgrade over Wallace.

This was a drive we can all live with.

Paging Joe in Winslow.

Easy.

This is the best post in the thread IMO and it is how this exercise makes most sense. It is much more useful to know how to construct complete winning team then just say that QB/DE/LT/whatever is most important. Thing is that you always have chance to have some elite players, some average and some clear weaknesses, and you have to realize this when constructing a roster. Good GM knows how to allocate resources. It is obviously more complicated than this, since you have 53 players on roster and not 24 (and having good CB3 might be for example more valuable than having good OLB2), but this is a good starting point. As for the model itself, I'd slightly change naming structure - you can't have 5 All-Pro players in this exercise. I would also avoid "Barely NFL Caliber" term when talking about starters. I'd say it should go like Elite/All Pro (2x), Pro Bowl (3x), Solid/Good Starter (7x), Avg Starter (7x), Borderline Starter/Backup Level (3x), Liability (2x). As a base your distribution 2/3/7/7/3/2 looks reasonable to me. I would also probably allow people to move players among groups, i.e. allow people to decide that they can upgrade one Liability to Borderline Starter in exchange for downgrading one Pro Bowl to Solid Starter etc. I don't pretend to be an expert but my initial thoughts are as follows: All Pros (2x): QB, LT Pro Bowl (3x): DE, CB, WR Good Starters (7x): C, RT, OG, MLB, DE2, DT, K (yes kicker here) Avg Starters (7x): OG, OLB, WR2, RB, TE, S, CB2 Backup Level (3x): DT2, OLB2, P Liability (2x): S, WR3

If Dolphins win, will we be betting favourites next week? ?

OP, why do you even care about the playoffs if Ravens and Dallas are automatic losses to you and all other games we will be lucky if we win?

I say let them score.

Well I couldn't be more wrong

I sense this is going to be brutal drive till the very end of the quarter playing with our hearts.

Well this was something.