Look at the top 10 from the last few years, I will highlight what I consider good films.
2004
1 Shrek 2 DreamWorks $441,226,247
2 Spider-Man 2 Sony $373,585,825
3 The Passion of the Christ Newmarket $370,274,604
4 Meet the Fockers Universal $277,206,540
5 The Incredibles Buena Vista $261,044,492
6 Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban Warner Bros. $249,541,069
7 The Day After Tomorrow Fox $186,740,799
8 The Bourne Supremacy Universal $176,241,941
9 National Treasure Buena Vista $170,642,906
10 The Polar Express Warner Bros. $162,775,358
2003
1 The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King New Line $377,027,325
2 Finding Nemo Buena Vista $339,714,978
3 Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Buena Vista $305,413,918
4 The Matrix Reloaded Warner Bros. $281,576,461
5 Bruce Almighty Universal $242,829,261
6 X2: X-Men United Fox $214,949,694
7 Elf New Line $173,398,518
8 Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines Warner Bros. $150,371,112
9 The Matrix Revolutions Warner Bros. $139,270,910
10 Cheaper by the Dozen Fox $138,614,544
2002
1 Spider-Man Sony $403,706,375
2 The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers New Line $339,789,881
3 Star Wars: Episode II — Attack of the Clones Fox $302,191,252
4 Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Warner Bros. $261,988,482
5 My Big Fat Greek Wedding IFC $241,438,208
6 Signs Buena Vista $227,966,634
7 Austin Powers in Goldmember New Line $213,307,889
8 Men in Black II Sony $190,418,803
9 Ice Age Fox $176,387,405
10 Chicago Miramax $170,687,518
2001
1 Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Warner Bros. $317,575,550
2 The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring New Line $313,364,114 3 Shrek DreamWorks $267,665,011
4 Monsters, Inc. Buena Vista $255,873,250
5 Rush Hour 2 New Line $226,164,286
6 Mummy Returns, The Universal $202,019,785
7 Pearl Harbor Buena Vista $198,542,554
8 Ocean's Eleven Warner Bros. $183,417,150
9 Jurassic Park III Universal $181,171,875
10 Planet of the Apes Fox $180,011,740
2000
1 How the Grinch Stole Christmas! Universal $260,044,825
2 Cast Away Fox $233,632,142
3 Mission: Impossible 2 Paramount $215,409,889
4 Gladiator DreamWorks $187,705,427
5 What Women Want Paramount $182,811,707
6 The Perfect Storm Warner Bros. $182,618,434
7 Meet the Parents Universal $166,244,045
8 X-Men Fox $157,299,717
9 Scary Movie Miramax $157,019,771
10 What Lies Beneath DreamWorks $155,464,351
1999
1 Star Wars: Episode I — The Phantom Menace Fox $431,088,301
2 The Sixth Sense Buena Vista $293,506,292
3 Toy Story 2 Buena Vista $245,852,179
4 Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me New Line $206,040,086
5 The Matrix Warner Bros. $171,479,930
6 Tarzan Buena Vista $171,091,819
7 Big Daddy Sony $163,479,795
8 The Mummy Universal $155,385,488
9 Runaway Bride Paramount $152,257,509
10 The Blair Witch Project Artisan $140,539,099
Note - The Green Mile was 12th in 1999, and I think that was a great movie.
So what that, 11 or 12 in about 7 years that are good-great. Not very good odds.