Okay I see where your coming from. I agree he had a better game numbers wise then Allen but Allen in the Vikings game also was great. My issue with Barkley is yes he will give you numbers but his TD to INT ratio is terrible. That's my hang up with him. Because our QB situation has been so horrible over the years I think Bill's fans sometimes want to turn somebody into something there not. Barkley has been given chances but hasn't capitalized on them long term.