I get what you are saying here, but there are some of us who knew Josh was far more talented than Peterman, McCarron, or some of his draft peers, and that he had untapped potential. A lot of the plays you see him making today escaping pressure, insane throws, hurdles, etc - he was doing that in college as well if you paid any attention (which most Bills fan didn't). He was just far more inconsistent in college due to the non-traditional path you reference and lack of upper level QB coaching. But you paint a picture that his college tape is garbage, I would argue inconsistent.