Scorp83

This means... Draft Winston late people... Mike Evan's will be a top 5 player in fantasy & you might be able to get him in the 2nd rd! #FantasyTip ??? Why is your user name purple?

I'm right here with you, everyone you've listed except I like Seattle... I'll replace Seattle with Washington... Dan Synder is unlikable

Or being a Troll if your on this board ?

The Eagles! Very close to my heart! But I've been a Bills fan since the 80's ... & I'll always root for them against the Eagles! But it's the Birds over everyone else except them Bills

Thank you! People are not understanding this logic

Not just saying this board lol... haven't based it off this poll either

That's good... your all in... most of us isn't. You can't be mad at that

Which doesn't prove anything... a coach making a stupid decision to sign Peterman doesn't make it smart or prove he's good. The same organization signed EJ after we released him... First year head coaches make mistakes all the time... & get blasted for it...McDermott isnt the exception. But as I laid out, it's not just one thing... McDermott isn't perfect & I love the risky moves but some of his risk isn't as calculated as he suggests. Some moves were just flat out stupid & shouldn't have been made

It's not, your ignoring him benching Tyrod for Peterman! That was #Facts! The game was winnable at the time #FACT If we didn't throw 5 INT's in the Chargers game... we would have controlled our own destiny. I NEVER SAID ANYTHING TOWARDS DISPUTING the "Dalton to Boyd Miracle" I know those things happen. What I'm saying is, we wouldn't have needed it in the 1st place... if our coach didn't make such a boneheaded decision that possibly costs us a game. That's why OP started this thread, so we can discuss McDermott approval rating. If you approve that's fine... but don't sit here & try to dispute his factual stupidity

No...but I knew there would be a sucker... which is why I posted the videos, cause a lot of people didn't want Allen. But, just how you used scouts that had him ranked high...there was also scouts that had him rank below Mason Rudolph. I've posted links during the predraft process The thing is, Allen was actually good. So alot of people were wrong...me included...but I've said this already.

Nate didn't fool everyone... after throwing 5 picks... it was nothing to be fool by. Preseason doesn't mean squat...WHY? Because it's the preseason...if your telling me McBeane was fooled by Nathan Peterman preseason games....then they shouldn't be in charge anymore! That's my point... & posters that was talking that Nathan's #1 crap... I didn't let that fly over my head. ?

I've mentioned the playoffs drought, I said because he foolishly bench Tyrod for Peterman...it caused us to cross our fingers for the Dalton to Boyd miracle

The part I under line, is my biggest thing about Allen...people on this board refuse to believe nobody really wanted Allen during pre draft evaluations. He's won me over, I will admit... but it's that anyone can argue that he was a highly touted prospect coming into the draft. See I don't fake my feelings & if I'm wrong I will admit it... There's literally a YouTube videos of Fans pissed off with the Allen pick! Check it out cause I was one of them ???

I did mention McBeane mishandled the QB position. But it was McDermott & his coaching staff that decided to cut McCarron. McDermott love for Peterman probably kept Beane from making the move though... I mean, that's just speculation, but we as fans have to look at the facts & fill in the gaps on our own. Beane probably had Anderson on speed dial, but who's to say McDermott didn't block it or & Beane was ok with backing his buddy's decision??? It's not like McDermott is perfect at making these kind of decisions. It's a good argument to have...& I think we all can agree we're glad they finally figured it out. But McDermott has power in that building, trust and believe...that was his call & Beane went along for the ride even if he was against the trip in the 1st place, Beane still gassed the car up & jumped in the passenger seat with an attitude ?

I voted No approval... -The Love for Nathan Peterman is almost sickening. -He doesn't answer any questions with Answers.... just gives us a bunch of words smh. -Even though the team last year wasn't that good... had a shot to win a big game against the Chargers, & he bench Tyrod for Peterman. That game cost us to cross our fingers, for Andy Dalton miracle to Tyler Boyd -He traded away our 11th pick to the Chiefs...instead of just taking Mahomes or Watson. - Choosing to RIP apart the roster was a little unnecessary, could have kept some of our players for 2018 if he would have just drafted Mahomes or Watson in 2017. - Not having a plan for our rookie QB after drafted... no O-Line, No WR's, Running game was effected because of some of the unnecessary moves. - The biggest one of all... Is realizing as a coaching staff McCarron wasn't going to make this roster, cuts him. Then announces Peterman as his week 1 starter, & doesn't replace a veteran presence to help both Josh & Peterman out. Those 2 pretty much had to bounce ideas & screw ups off each other before Anderson was signed. Then it took a 3rd or 4th time (I can't remember cause it just shouldn't have been that many times!!!) Of starting Peterman to realize "this kid just doesn't have the juice" to get rid of him. WOW! We were literally a joke for half the season because of the way McBeane mishandled the QB position. There's ways to get a QB, McDermott's way was just a little unnecessary. But I'm still in the middle. I don't like his clock management but like Allen... I think it will get better. So I don't want to ding him for that too much. I do like his core values but that doesn't mean he's a winner. Like how he gets fired up for the plays when we're struggling as a team. His heart is in the right place but so was Dick Jauron's heart.

No vote for "In the Middle"

Love the train... it's part of the Ralph

Neither did Ray... can't blame him for being around people he grew up with.

Saints Vs. Chiefs... Saints winning & Brees retiring on top like Ray Lewis did a few years ago

He's not seeing the end of that deal... he traded Mack & Cooper... he's already on the Hot Seat... he'll be gone after his 3rd year

I don't think he's talking about Mock Drafts ? You can't control the draft... I feel like Mike is the most accurate Draft Analyst out here, his mocks never go as plan, but the players always end up turning into good players 3-4 years later. That's my fear for him, Gruden doesn't have enough time imo... so they're not going to give Mayock that much time either. So many players he said would be great, turned up great....not just good. Big Ben Antonio Brown Kerryon Johnson (soon will be) Mike Evans Odell Beckham over Sammy Khalil Mack Russell Wilson Cam Newton (when everyone went Gabbert) Just to name a few Heck... he even hit on EJ in the worst QB draft ever! EJ ended up be the best one... out of all the sucky prospects. & before you grill me on that comment, remember nobody knew how bad it was & Mayock was the main one saying "this is a bad class & if I had to take one of these players, I'll take the mobile big arm kid from Florida State" That's knowing your stuff... though the best move was to just punt on the whole QB class

Heck no they didn't think he would be this good. They took him 7th overall & probably would have moved up higher to do it. Just because they took him high doesn't mean they knew he was good... look how many busts QB's went in the top 10 since 2000! Their previous actions proved they had no clue what they were doing... Rex actually left this team with more talent then, than what we have now. We didn't have to rebuild... the team was good during Rex era... they just needed to get the defense right. Nobody told McDermott to rip apart the offense... & not replace the talent. No yea... the only thing they can sale to you, was a "Rebuild" It was the only thing you & most of the fanbase could except to cover up stupidity. But hey, I can already tell... McDermott can't do no wrong in your eyes... so continue to turn a blind eye to benching Tyrod for Peterman, Trading away Watkins, Passing on Mahomes (cause apparently, through their evaluation...that you seem to trust so much...he wasn't good enough to draft at 11th), Started Peterman again over Allen...might I add, & I'm not touching his decision making & clock management during games... But hey... this is crazy to even speak of & this will probably be the 2nd dumbest thing you've read in a while. Smh... ????? Happy New Year's buddy. Go Bills... prayfully this front office get it right & help this Kidd... cause man... he saved their butts.

Devil's Advocate: You do realize he tried not to go to the playoffs right? He bench our starting QB in a winnable game while we had control of our own destiny at the time. He in Peterman which became the laughing stock of the league. Then doubled down on it this year... We barely made the playoffs & needed a miracle to get in... it happened & yes it was fun... but we didn't need to do all that if our coach wasn't a bonehead to begin with. #ImJusSayin

This is a great legitimate question! Most posters will wonder why your saying this buddy ? But if anyone has been paying attention. This front office has made countless mistakes, they can evaluate talent. The offensive moves they've made the past 2 years has not paid off! It's hard to trust their judgment!!! Example, Draft season I was banging the table to NOT draft Allen. Yet McBeane takes him anyway...I just added it the the failure of moves this front office has made, but Allen proved everyone wrong, including the Coaching Staff... yet they picked Peterman over him during training camp. Smh I think we lucked up on Allen being good... I was wrong... & I think McBeane were wrong in their evaluation too... they probably didn't think the Kidd would be this good....this early either... if they did, they wouldn't have kept Peterman starting for so long. Then mismanaging the QB position entirely was almost fireable. But we do need continuity... & we do fire coaches left & right. But like you said... Are we wasting another year with McDermott? That's tough cause I don't think McDermott is the right guy for the job. I haven't even touched on his game management skills either

Today I really enjoyed watching Allen play... the kid has really turn things into his favor. I was one of his biggest critics coming out of college... now it seems like we have the 2nd best QB from this draft class. I'm still jury out .. but I'm willing to support his kid & see where he grows. We have something...before I thought we had nothing. I'm excited for this offseason!