PolishPrince

Doesn't Coleman play slot CB for us in "big packages?"

Yeah I was just talking to someone about this. Josh will be in his third year, and it will be his third regular season win over the Titans

Exactly. For having so many guys on the roster only for ST... I would expect them to be better So then why do we need Senorise Perry? Neal is the only gunner I see actually making plays

Here you go:

If I had to think of it in a "positive spin." A lot of people around here have been saying Wallace is bad anyway, so if we had to lose 1 defensive starter he hurts the least... I dont actually agree with these takes, I think he has been great in coverage personally - just gets more light shined on him due to teams not going after white as much for obvious reasons...... And Neshke: To be honest, his first injury I thought was much more severe and he wouldnt be back at all, so it is almost a wash IMO. I wish we had him though

Did you really take what I said is that Singletary is worse than Yeldon? What is wrong with you lol... I even said I love Singletary. And "Rugby guy cant play a down in playoffs." he is a free EXTRA practice squad spot. Can you please explain to me how this is a negative thing in someway? Normally you get I think 10 practice squad guys... we are now allowed 11 if it's "rugby guy." How is this a bad thing in any way shape or form?

And I can think of multiple games this year where people were wanting our ST coach fired because our coverage was mediocre to poor and we were miscuing on plays. If you have 4+ members on your active roster dedicated solely for niche special teams role (not including P/K) then you should be better IMO. Siran Neal is the MUCH better gunner than Foster, and Neal has contributed in the secondary all year. I agree with you, not sure what people saw Yeldon do to cement an active place - I just dont think he is as bad as others claim with the fumbles. Duke and Sweeney need to be starting over some combination of Perry, Foster, Smith, DiMarco....IMO.

What a terrible all around take. So again, like I said... Yeldon fumbles once in preseason, and once in regular season and that makes him super fumble prone? I love Singletary... but since taking over workload he has two games with 2x fumbles. Fumbling was never his issue in Jax lol. And you are 100% wrong in "not keeping Murphy to keep a rugby gimmick player that cant dress." We also cut Mr. Rugby, and brought him back as an EXTRA FREE practice squad player. He doesnt count against our limit lol

Then let Hyde fair catch again. We essentially have 4 gimmick players. 1 returner only. 2x gunner only in Perry and Foster, and McKenzie only used on sweeps and faking a sweep.... not to mention we also have DiMarco who plays like 10 snaps at most a game (but is special teams ace), and a pure blocking TE in Smith. With all of our special teams ace's I wonder why our ST still has such poor days. Its like 50-50 if they are going to be fantastic, or crap.

The problem is our #4 and #5 are pretty much only special teamers in Roberts and Foster... our #3 is a gadget player. We need to either focus getting the TE's involved more, or sit Foster and put in Duke. As decent as Roberts has been returning kicks this year, I wont be upset if his injury lingers another week. Let McKenzie return kicks, Foster stays for gunning, and Duke gets called up for Roberts

IN fairness, Stills is decent

Nah, we got McKenzie ?

Rookie of the year should go to Singletary IMO...

He fumbled once in preseason... then once in like first game of the season suddenly "all he does is fumble." I wonder what that makes Singletary fumbling twice in one game ?

Need to sit Foster and Lee "yellow flag" Smith. Loved Foster last year... but he really isnt showing anything all year

I wonder if anyone still thinks this..... I remember the threads early in the season lol

This is so overblown

He needs to be active over Foster. McKenzie and Andre Holmes serve different roles. I dont care if Foster plays special teams, find someone else. Foster was a feel good story last year, he obviously has a ton of speed... but he doesnt fight for contested balls and has depth judgement issues. Duke can make contested grabs, has that edge to him, provides us with a big body for once and also is a fantastic blocker.

Because the last thing we need is a deep drop and Allen taking an unnecessary hit

What about Ryan Bates also?

This is actually one of the reasons I hate Duke Williams being inactive every week. He has shown to be a tremendous blocker...I am actually shocked they didnt value this part of his game more

Could very well be. I just know its not a gimme throw like some are suggesting. He is open but up and over defenders, while competing with back of endzone - as he is still running deep

It boggles me why we always play soft one vs Pats.... Brady for years has lived in 4> yard throws... why would you not press WR and live underneasth?

Again our defense has been holding teams to around 200-250 yards of offense. We just allowed 450 to a struggling Pats offense

yes, close throw... but that is in no way an easy throw... he is trying to thread that up and over multiple defenders, but get to knox before he goes Out of bounds