BuffaloRush

You have to understand Elway. He doesn’t want to trade up and was burned by the Paxton Lynch experiment. If he likes Mayfield he takes him. But I don’t see a trade up

You Doug Whaley is that you? Because the author of that response has no idea how to build a team

Theres a reason they traded all of those players - they didn’t want them! Also to my knowledge Hughes has not been traded. Glenn - lopsided contract Tyrod - contract; performance Darby - poor fit in defense i agree with you - the team does need to find a QB in this year’s draft. The Foles trade won’t happen, but if it did most of the fans would be pissed

It worked really well for EJ Manuel.

Not true... it’s been reported that Whaley loved Mitch Trubisky

I think they are ok with AJ as starter, as long as there’s a rookie QB waiting to take over. That’s why there’s no way the Bills don’t draft a 1st round QB.

Enjoy the beaucoup talent.... that doesn’t have a QB

Greg Gabriel also thought Peterman was a great QB prospect

Not happening. Maybe if the Bills didn’t sign McCarron

Would not be happy with Rudolph

Enjoy QB Purgatory

Well said! Name a QB that was drafted in recent history (outside of Andrew Luck maybe) that didn’t have the “faults” you mention?

But can you really see this administration come away without drafting a QB after planning to do so for nearly 1 year? I can see them throwing their hands up in the air and saying “oh well, we tried.” I really hope it doesn’t happen because it’s that type of “kick the QB can down the road” mentality that got the franchise into QB purgatory for years. This team need a QB

Its not fake news, it’s an opinion. And there are many people in this forum who want the Bills to draft OL or DL at #12.

Great analysis

Only a snowflake would complain about people staring threads in a message board. Get a life

Jeremy says it all right here. This team has been drafting every position but QB the past 30 years. If they don’t get a QB this year, they basically failed the entire strategy they planned one year ago.

Its entirely possible, but let’s hope for a miracle Maybe, it makes sense. Of course, this goes against everything that’s been reported. That’s like me saying I’m certain the Browns will draft B Chubbs at #1.

Right, different situation here. The majority of the media is saying “The Giants are going to pass on drafting a QB at #2.” Thats the general consensus as of 3/17/18. If you read the threads since the Jets made their move, there’s a good majority of members at TBD who make it sound like it’s a given that the Giants are taking a QB. It’s fine to think that, and maybe even a very logical thought, but it’s far from a certainty that people make it sound like.

...Or if he made the trade with the Bills, he has adds 3 new starters (on rookie deals) with the potential to add more in 2019. There is merit to taking the picks

I can see why NYG would take a QB at #2, but most reporters who cover the NFL are saying that they appear in the direction of doing the opposite. i don’t see why everyone is predicting here is they’ll take a QB at #2, like it’s a given. It’s not a given like it with Cleveland at #1. Take a look at any of the Beane/NYJ posts. I don’t doubt this for one second. I do think he’ll give Beane the first chance to get fleeced!

“Last month, TheMMQB.com's Peter King wrote, "Much smarter NFLers than I told me in the last few days they think GM Dave Gettleman will pass on a quarterback to fill another major need at number two overall, and I don't doubt it," which adds credence to the notion that adding a passer at the top of the draft may not be a priority. And if Gettleman truly is of the belief that filling other "major needs" is critical to prompt a Giants turnaround, New York is in the catbird seat. With quarterback-needy teams particularly desperate this time of year, all Gettleman has to do is wait for the phone to ring and field offers. Our colleague Will Brinson detailed all of Gettleman's options in this comprehensive post from several weeks ago.”

Exhibit B http://www.nj.com/giants/index.ssf/2018/03/nfl_draft_after_jets_trade_giants_hold_trade_market.html Exhibit C https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/heres-why-the-jets-colts-trade-is-great-news-for-browns-giants-and-bad-news-for-bills-broncos/

They a tad bit more informed than a lot of us. I agree - the accuracy with mock drafts is super low Exhibit A: https://giantswire.usatoday.com/2018/02/19/new-york-giants-pass-on-qb-2018-nfl-draft-growing-belief/

I agree. Dorsey is taking Darnold and that’s a lock. I do believe they wish there was a way for them to come away with Darnold and Barkley.