gobills1212

Ya? If thats what youd like... I just hope next time you decide to 'police' someone 'policing' you see its simply criticizing someone for criticizing. Its redundant and rather than being noble it just gets lost in the wash and you end up here wondering why you bothered in the 1st place

I wasn't wrong my man. When there is more substance and thought in your title than your actual post - your post is pretty weak. Do i need to explain click bait to you? Disguising a topic like there is something within pertaining to the topic you tease (like a quote from a pundit or something to back up said title) only to ask a question bc you want discussion (that litterally has its own thread already where the Bills are being mocked QW) is silly. OP question is answered to his hearts content there. As far as hypocrisy is concerned, you litterally told me to be nice and if i didnt like it to move on. IE voicing displeasure over content that you dont deem appropriate. If that isnt the pot calling the kettle black im not sure what is. Rather than throw it in your face I simply alluded to it in my 1st response. Now, i will actually tell you to heed your own advice and move on.

Lol, oh dopey... You took time out of your day for this? At the very least, i hope you feel better now:) Next time we can discover how sarcasim works! We'll also be discussing the wonderful world of novel responses!! We wont however, cover hypocrisy as youve obviously got that down pat...

I dont know. Neither do they. Ill never understand why people ask unanswerable questions to prompt discussion rather than simply saying 'i think' or 'id like or hope'. Point #2 - if you need to brainstorm a click baity title for your post, your post prob sucks as the whole point of click bait is to get a click that wouldn't happen otherwise bc whats insdie is lame.

If a tree falls in the woods and no one is around to hear it does it make a sound? These people can make proclamations and predictions bc they cant be proven wrong. Asking a question no one knows the answer too is along the same lines fwiw

THIS is one of the things that made/makes this place awesome. This place was once full of stuff like this prior to topics letting us know the color socks they were wearing today. JW is one of the few gems that still grace us with his info/presence. Good stuff

...he actually said in public. Yikes man, yikes

Whatever you do, dont post this at The Gang Green lol. For Jets fans, context isnt a thing. Absolutely blows me away!

I have a special face plant dent on my deak reserved for threads such as this...

Its all relative - i hadnt made a single comment about what the OP actually authored this post about. The convo evolved w each response from you. If you want to 'argue' one thing fine - but at this point it feels more like a circle bc we just keep going round and dont even necessarily disagree. AFAIC the only point thats worth consideration is most fans can at least name each teams qb along w a wr. Many cant get the wr for buffalo bc foster hasnt ensablished himself and this isnt a household name UNTIL he goes out there and makes himself one - which was my point. You can be certian itll happen if youd like, but my argument was it hasnt happened yet and im not counting eggs before they hatch no matter how convinced you are.

Now this is just splitting hairs. If you have any friends that are fans of other teams try having a convo about how they need to be scared of Foster. If they agree and dont elaborate, odds are they are patronizing you. They wont be shaking in their boots and thats WITH the benefit (assuming you reside in WNY) of them knowing who he is. WE like him becuase he is a nice player with potential on OUR team. Its neither here no there, but Jets fans would laugh you off the Gang Green board if you 'threatened ' them with Foster. Im not comfortable with this narrative in that im painted into a corner of acting like Im a Foster detractor. I can get behind a qlty 1st yr. I can get behind the potential of a very good WR. I can even get beind continuing to progress and picking up where he left off last year. I cant however sit here and act like hes had his coming out party and is now a respected and feared weapon. That hasnt been achieved yet IMO. You seem certian it will happen, and again, i hope it does. But as of now, all he has to hang his hat on is last year. Not projections, or you being certain it will happen. Once again, the only thing that will change that is producing in games. As weve seen winning in the off season is no big thing when bullets start flying. The jury is still out in the same way the RQB class of 18 is out. As Bills fans we are excited about Allen. Jets fans arent scared. The only thing that changes that is by making it so, when it counts, and there are tangible results. Potential can only strike so much fear in opponents.

Which again, is awesome and it can do nothing but help. AT THIS MOMENT, outside of Buffalo, no one is really respecting/fearing or considering the kid a legitimate threat/weapon. I HOPE that is different this time next year and he is a budding FWR in the making, becomes to Allen what Reed was to Kelly, and has gotten both recognition and pro bowl looks. I GET being jacked about a player, Ive defended Allen on other teams boards but at the end of the day peoples minds dont change on projections - they change with results. Thats why my last couple responses have kinda changed directions from what he was to was to pumping the breaks on annointing the kid as the man as if he has achieved something other than his half of a good year. I like your confidence and hope, but its getting to the point where you either A) have a crystal ball and know whats up next year qnd cant tell us or B) have some sort of personal investment in his success. Thats not at all an insult btw - i just cant imagine being this sold on someone unless you legit know something the rest of us dont.

I just think Im not AS impressed with you after a qlty half season of football. I litterally hope you are correct!!

Another reason for optimism but its kinda crazy there isnt a gauge. As it sits now he could be their best redzone threat and he could also not even make the roster. The hope however is what makes it fun and interesting!

I seem to be pegged as thinking otherwise, but I agree with this. The kid showed flashes (stand out plays being long plays) and improvements as well as potential BUT a good half year isnt a huge revalation for any NFL player. He could kill it. He coukd not break through. Im a positive spin Bills fan, but im also trying to not be a homer and anoint the kid a star before he has accomplished and posted a standout season as a whole on his resume. Im not at all calling anyone a homer with blind optimism but in reading boards for other teams theres nothing worse than fans who think every quality player is a star in the making. Within reason i try to avoid being a hypocrite

I dont disagree Doc, and i appreciate the links. I was impressed when it read it when it was written and I cant help but feel like you are trying to defend a point that isnt being argued. Im not trashing on Foster. Maybe he starts from the get - and maybe he takes that and runs with it. Maybe production lacks and he slips. A guy can do everything right and sometimes it just doesnt translate. We are all just as impressed with Allen, and same thing- he has the work ethic qnd the whole 9... its not a guarentee he will be a star. The sophomore slump is a real thing. Sometimes players experience it through no fault of their own. The end result is you cant change the way I feel. I feel better than I did about Zay after yr 1 (issues aside) but Foster is going to have to continue to do his thing and improve before the league takes him as a serious threat, and bringing this full circle, makes the pro bowl.

Lol, ive seen it multiple times and respectfully please dont act like youve seen something i havent- as ill guess you have by your statment ive taken the time to watch each snap a couple times. Not that its a pissing contest bc i dont mean it to sound that way in the least - just that IF theres a difference in opinion it wont be anything other than we had different takeaways from the same source material. Also, in my followup (to Doc) im not even arguing it as it was more of a general statment as he showed growth and the ability to do different things but lets be real, his talent and game as a reciver has yet to come to fruition. If he was doing everything consistently well people outside of BUF would actually know who he was or not look at you like you have 3 heads if your rebuttel is " well, ya but we have Foster". Like Allen, the kid was showing flashes and growing into his talents. Both could have a killer year, but have yet to totally establish themselves as anything but talented players w potential. The original statment was projecting him as a pro bowler next year. I just think based on what hes flashed thats a bit of reach next year. IMO Allen would be more likley BUT again, i dont predict the future:)

We will see - and thats part of the fun- theres no way to know. IMO just another aspect to a potentially reallt exciting year. Progress as a whole would be fun to watch and theyve finally been patient, have added the tools, and have taken steps where they could be a really good team on the rise. Personally, outside of a few pundits i dont think the Bills have been given a ton of credit. Other fans bases and some national as well still seem to think theyll be a doormat with a poor young qb. I think if all goes right this team could be a pleasant suprise. That said, Rex won himself an offseason too so we wont know until the bullets start flying how it shakes out. The Foster question is an excellent representation of the team as a whole imo. It could go really well, it could go bad, and it could be simply the next step to becoming a competitive football team.

He may very well not be, but Im hoping (like allen) that the strides we got to watch him make over the course of long 'learning' season were the building blocks to the next level this coming season. Now that there are 'proven commodities' in the WR room (undoubtedly there will be varying opinions as to how 'proven' they be⚓#yarr-hownisntherenopirateenoji??) Im very interested to see if he continues his ascension to be a genuine weapon or if he struggles to stay relevant and only gets deep balls on occasion as a 3rd or 4th option. I hope its the former but we arent out of the woods yet IMO.

I hope so. Im not sure why, but when people we say ' well we have Foster' that never really excited me. Maybe bc he was the 'best' of a bad bunch. Id like to see him be more than a 1 trick pony. Its a good trick, dont get me wrong, but he was essentially like a Goodwin (a burner who was faster) but he could catch (always felt that a ball was 50/50 even in Goodwins bucket). Maybe I was still a little down from early season errors. I dont dislike the guy and hope he excells at his role ESP of Brown happens to garner more attn outside and deep. I just am more hoping he can cement himself in a followup campagin than thinking Pro Bowl

Common though, extension = more buyout $ and more $ for a raise. Wink wink type stuff

This reads like a craigs list personals ad

I dont disagree, but i dont get why people are poo pooing this. Im all in on the Allen fan wagon. I think fans have a right to be excited. Allen is fun for all the right reasons as discussed all over this forum. Same way Jets and Browns fans are taken w their rookie qb. For fans of these teams, the sky is the limit. That said, its tough to be real about it and step back. Outside if Baker, no one has really proved anything. Baker will need to follow last years season up as well. Lots of reason for optimism, but passing judgment on any of these guys good or bad is still premature. Its a ton of fun to be optimistic, but lets not act like these guys futures are already carved in stone for better or worse. Rosen could change teams and come in and look like many Bills fans hoped he would look here in a few years - FQBish Allen has flipped a lot of the pundits who were on the fence to admit he flashed potential but his detractors still arent fans. Darnold and Baker have Cowherd banging their drums and even he is guilty of acting too certian (fwiw, he is a tool - but he fits the bill). Nationally, even guys in allens corner arent screaming his praise from the roof tops. Itll be a fun year and hopefully next yr Allen has the national love sam and baker have. But as of now, all the allen love is oretty region specific - and thats ok w me

Lol, i get how media works but the interest its soliciting is dwindling and the feedback isnt exactly great which again leads back to the qlty of speculation. You might think its a wonderful topic to lead a conversation on but for example was THIS SPECIFIC speculation being discussed? No. Were there plenty of other draft speculation threads that could have sufficed as a platform or medium for you to pose your question? Undoubtedly. If it doesnt get legs there then its probably not worth a thread devoted to it. Look, im not in a position to say what is and isnt a quality post. What i think is good discussion you might not and vice versa. To each their own. During a high news period its a moot point. Im just saying it was a little annoying to click on a topic that from the outside looks like it might be a good read because of the tease title only to find out its just some random speculation that is really neither here nor there. Like the Pats dynasty thing. If youve watched football for the past however many odd years you know with brady and coach they are good enough to plug and play and turn which ever new or washed up part into a player of relavance. So did we really need a post with a click bait title only to speculate on how long itll last? Im just saying, if its found annoying and then a few hours later someone falls for it again eventually either no one clicks or the entire topic is laughing at the topic. Then your message board experience isnt any fun anymore either so everyone loses. No?