People say why they dislike her all the time. She hasn't gotten much better at all. Like, at all. She is basically the same as when she started. She is NOT prepared for every show because she doesn't have the football knowledge to be of value. Her go-to contribution is to repeat everything that Chris Brown says in a longer and more confusing way. She fills her allotted speaking time with fluff and filler words while saying basically nothing. I'm not as annoyed by her voice as many, but it certainly doesn't enhance anything.
This particular topic about the question and Josh's answer is a big nothing burger, but everything fans complain about with her is true.
Just as you accuse fans of hating her because she is a woman, I think the ones who defend her do it only because she is a woman.