Pros to Luck:
-Smart player
-If healthy (big if) can be a winner
-He's very polite
-He's not named Tyrod Taylor
-Can read a defense and play at a high level
-Has playoff experience
Cons to Luck
-This shoulder issue may never fully heal. Word I have seen is he's in Europe getting some weird treatment. Doesn't sound like the typical route an NFL player takes to recovery
-Poor lines in Indy mean he has been hit more than a woman dating Chris Brown (the R&B singer...Not the Bills reporter)
-He's already 28 with high mileage on his body
-Would take a ton of draft capital to get him
-On top of the picks would be an enormous salary
My opinion: Use all those picks that we would have to give up and build a team. Look, we let Gilmore go and used that money to sign Poyer and Hyde plus have some leftover. That's how to build a team. The money saved from not having Luck could get us a rookie QB, a new RG and perhaps a new LBer. It's a no brainer for me. Give me a revamped team over a guy who "kinda sorta could heal and be ok" or kinda sorta could be done and could be the next RGIII