Sky Diver

Than why did Buffalo trade him and sign McCarron?

I think it’s way more than that.

Define “body of work”. One half of football?

McCarron is mid tier with the potential to move into the top third.

Probably his first incompletion then we’ll be hearing how inaccurate he is.

The Peterman hate is over the top too. In the SD game he had no blocking and he lost his top receiver early in the game. He’s a capable backup.

We significant upgraded the QB position since last year. Allen is a stud and McCarron is better then Taylor. I don’t get the hand wringing and gloom and doom.

I’ll reserve judgement until McCarron or Allen actually throw a pass.

Look at Flutie’s and RJ’s record with the same D.

Don’t let facts get in the way of reality. Keep spewing.

The teams that picked Mayfield, Darnold and Allen ahead of Rosen don’t know what they are looking at either? I think you need to end your Rosen crusade and stop embarrassing yourself, especially since he plays for another team.

UCLA went 10 - 3 the year before Rosen, to 8-5, 4-8 and 6-7 with Rosen.

I actually watch the games rather than spouting stats.

He was the fourth QB selected in the draft. That indicates how he was valued by NFL teams.

I didn’t think he played well at all in the A&M game in 2017. I saw a complete breakdown of the A&M defense. Yes, to counter your claim that Rosen is such a great QB.

Oh, so you cherry pick his good games to make your case for him? He wasn’t good in the 2nd A&M game either. The A&M defense melted down in the 2nd half. You should really watch both games. He even managed to shoot off his mouth before the game in classical Rosen style to turn the A&M fans against him. https://sportsday.dallasnews.com/college-sports/texasamaggies/2016/09/03/texas-am-fans-make-fun-uclas-josh-rosen-chanting-50000 Why are you crusading for a guy who isn’t even a Bill?

Yes, Rosen was awful in the 2016 game against A&M. Even he acknowledged it. https://www.google.com/amp/www.theeagle.com/aggie_sports/football/mistakes-haunt-ucla-qb-josh-rosen-in-loss-to-texas/article_2a36d7bb-e4a8-525f-af51-13da3a897864.amp.html

Did you see “demonstrated ability to read defenses and go through progressions on an advanced level to deliver the ball quickly” in the A&M game? I didn’t. I saw poor decision making, mostly single reads or looking down receivers, poor pocket presence, and a lot of highly inaccurate throws. You obviously haven’t watched the game. He was 26 of 46 with 3 interceptions.

Mayfield, Darnold and Allen were all chosen before Rosen. So in you expert opinion, all of the NFL teams and their advanced scouting departments got it wrong when they didn’t pick Rosen? How about the interception at 0:25 in the A&M game? Can you share your thoughts about Rosen’s decision making on that play?

Rosen was the fourth QB taken in the draft. That shows what NFL teams thought about him. You thought the A&M game I linked showed advanced QB play? What specifically did you see that led you to that conclusion? You are clearly seeing something NFL teams didn’t because Rosen was the fourth QB selected in the draft.

So you watched the video of the A&M game and you can tell me you see advanced QB play?

Sounds good, but is it true? Not from what I have seen. If he is so advanced, why was he the fourth QB taken in the draft?

Rosen is overhyped and overrated. Watch this and tell me there aren’t serious issues with his game as far as accuracy and decision making. There is a reason he was the 4th QB taken in the draft.

Poor decisions and wildly inaccurate. Allen? No, Rosen. He turned the A&M fans against him too. https://sportsday.dallasnews.com/college-sports/texasamaggies/2016/09/03/texas-am-fans-make-fun-uclas-josh-rosen-chanting-50000

You clearly didn’t watch the video.