I'm a Josh homer; he's the best QB this franchise has ever seen. However, even after all of the BS during the game of questionable play calls, officiating, etc., we still had an opportunity to win it. If Norwood makes the FG, we beat the Giants in SB25, even after all of the missed tackles, poor run defense, etc. If we squib kick it, there probably is no 13 seconds loss to talk about.
When we had 3:33 left in the game, all three timeouts, and a chance to go up by 4 points while eating up the clock with our run game, I told my wife "Here's your chance to be the game-winning hero, Josh." Failure. Say all you want about the Worthy catch/non-catch, missed 4th down play, porous defense; we still had a chance to win the game and our offense couldn't get it done.
Josh had his chance with 3 minutes to go. He couldn't get it done. We watched the same game; on our last possession, he threw a ball to where he thought Shakir was going to go, didn't scramble straight ahead when it was there, and didn't recognize a corner blitz that hurried his throw to Kincaid.
I'm not saying this is all his fault, but he is certainly not blameless.