I get it.
But Purdy doesn't have to deal with Mahomes, Allen, Burrow, Lamar or even Stroud in his conference. Plus he also has an All Pro at every skill position.
No, it's not.
We got a good look the first 10 games of the season watching "neutered" Josh and it wasn't pretty. Josh is at his best when the threat of him running is always there. Taking that away makes defenses breathe easy.
I see it this way as well but I'm not putting Josh over Mahomes. I might put Stroud over Herbert and replace Lawrence with Love who I would place over Hurts.
This past season when the powers that be tried to change and pull the reins on our QB we crapped away over half the season. Honestly, if Dorsey just stuck and got creative with the run game more often instead of abandoning it so soon in a game and didnt discourage Josh from running he probably would of yielded similar results to Brady.
Let Josh be Josh. He's the most durable and physically imposing QB in the league. His prime years shouldn't be wasted trying to bubble wrap him.
I agree with this. Unfortunately injuries are part of the game and sometimes you just need a little luck on your side.