SoTier

Any player can be injured and never play again as well he did pre-injury. Nothing is ever guaranteed. The Bills could stand pat at #30 in the 2025 draft and draft a DLer there who might take 2-4 years to reach potential or they could package their 2025 first and one of their seconds as well as their 2026 first to move up to the middle of the first round to take a better DL prospect who might need only a season or two to reach his potential. That DLer could also suffer an injury in TC and never play as a rookie. That happened with QB JJ McCarthy in Minnesota this past season. The draft is a crap shoot. Half of all first round draft picks are either out right busts or disappointments or they get injured early on and never play as well as they did before the injury.

Plan B would be don't bother with him. Actually, that would be Plan A.

Or maybe the Bills have just had a run of bad luck. Do you really think that the Commanders would have beaten the Lions in the Divisional Round if they don't have 16 players on IR for that game, including their best defender, Aidan Hutchinson? Untrue. They didn't have Rapp. They didn't have Benford.

Was Stefon Diggs an UDFA or a refugee from the waiver wire??? Is the Bills OL trash???? For the love of God, STOP LYING TO ADVANCE YOUR AGENDA.

Why are you comparing a rookie DT to DTs who have been in the NFL for decades? If you want to "prove" how bad Carter was as a rookie by using statistics, then use them fairly. Compare rookies to each other, not to veterans.

There were 219 rookie DTs in the 2024???? I think not. Tre White was drafted #27 in the first round. Cole Bishop was drafted #60 (#28 in the second round) which is much closer to the third round than to the bottom of the first round where White was drafted . If he was ready to play in the NFL, he would have been gone before #60.

I don't know if the Bills would have won any SBs with Whaley as GM but I think that they might have a stronger roster. Whaley knew talent. As a GM, he was never totally in charge because he reported to Russ Brandon, who was dedicated to maximizing profits rather winning football games. Whaley was continually forced to scramble to fill holes when Brandon decided the Bills couldn't "afford" to pay one good player after another. When he was fired after the 2017 draft, there was a lot of speculation that Whaley wanted to draft Mahomes at #10 and clashed with McDermott over that. McDermott won, and Whaley was gone. Beane -- and McDermott -- lucked out when Brandon was forced to resign in 2018 because of complaints that he was sexually harassing female employees of the Sabres.

Carter is a DT, and DTs generally take longer to develop than DEs, especially when they're late Day 2 picks (#31 in the third round). He was also injured IIRC.

So it might have been Monos/Nix. Even under Nix, Whaley evaluated most of the talent. As bad as Manuel was, I will acquit Monos/Nix/Whaley of being so incompetent as to pick Manuel in the first round because they all reported to Russ Brandon, and Brandon wanted a QB in the first round even though there were no QB prospects worth taking in the first round. Ralph Wilson was dying, and the team was going to be sold, so Brandon wanted a full stadium in 2013 to demonstrate the team's profitability to prospective buyers. He saw a first round QB as the best way to achieve that given how crappy the Bills had been of late. When the "message" is an opinion, the "messenger's" agenda matters, dude. "My dog is a German Short-haired Pointer" is a fact. "German Short-haired Pointers are better than Dachsunds" is an opinion. That I owned a GSP for 15 years and that I do not like ankle-biter dogs just might have a little something to do with my opinion.

He could be. If the Panthers get him an OL and some weapons, he might blossom. Did you forget that Josh Allen didn't look very promising on a really talent-deprived Bills team in 2018? He improved significantly between his rookie and sophomore season, but even in his third season, lots of analysts still doubted him.

I think that a lot of people said something similar to that about Bryce Young. He even started 2024 poorly, but then "the light came on" and he played really well the rest of the season. Certainly down the stretch, he played better than last year's OROY CJ Stroud. Players making a big jump between their rookie and sophomore seasons is very common.

Point 1 -- Coleman didn't seem to be as good when he returned from his injury as he had been before. Point 2 -- In the Divisional game, Coleman drew a PI that set up a Bills TD ... that kind of contribution doesn't show up on the stat line. Point 3 -- KC traded up to get Worthy. Maybe if they had traded up to get a better OT prospect, they might have their three-peat. Even if Suamataia becomes an All Pro in year 3, that doesn't change the past. James Cook is very definitely a blue chipper. Diggs wasn't a FA. The Bills traded their first round pick in 2020 to get him from Minnesota. The Bills signed guard Connor McGovern from Dallas in 2023 and he played very well. In 2024, he moved over to center to replace Mitch Morse -- and he played even better and earned a Pro Bowl berth. You don't always get what you want, dude. Deal with it.

Did you actually check on what Mitchell did as a rookie before you claimed he '"would make much more sense" than Coleman? Adonai MItchell: 17 games, 7 games started, 55 targets, 23 receptions, 312 yards, 0 TDs, 36 long Keon Coleman: 13 games, 12 games starter, 57 targets, 29 receptions, 556 yards, 4 TDs, 64 long Covering your butt, are you? IMO, there MIGHT some posters here who aren't declaring the 2024 draft a definite failure but there sure are numerous ones absolutely tarring and feathering the the Bills FO. I thought that Beane's sin was not investing enough in defensive tackle. Teams have finite resources -- draft picks, cap space, roster spots, etc -- that have to be juggled. FTR, the Bills did make a major investment in WR ... they spent a first round pick in 2020 to acquire Stefon Diggs. They didn't count on him only lasting three years with the team before he went looking for greener pastures. Moreover, if the Bills continually spent their limited draft resources on WRs or DTs or whatever position wanna be GMs on this MB wanted, they would not have been able to build one of the best OLs in the NFL to protect their MVP QB. Josh Allen says "hi". Since you are so down on the Bills, I think you should raid your piggy bank to buy into an NFL team. I understand the Giants are looking for some minority owners -- and with they're such a talent-laden team, all of their Day 1 and Day2 draft picks should be able to start from Day 1, especially if their GM -- and yours -- listens to you.

Exactly right. Monos was part of a failed regime, and McDermott and Beane have exposed how badly they failed. Lookiing at just how they drafted in the first two rounds of their drafts exposes the failures of the Monos/Whaley regime. Monos/Whaley's first and second round picks: 2013: #16 QB EJ Manuel , #41 WR Robert Woods), #46 LB Kiko Alonzo 2014: #4 WR Sammy Watkins, #44 OT Cyrus Kouandijo 2015: #50 DB Ronald Darby 2016: #19 DE Shaq Lawson, #41 LB Reggie Ragland In 2015, Darby was runner up in DROY voting. In 2014, Watkins had 982 yards. In 2015 he had 1047 yards. Playing with Mahomes in 2019, he had 673 yards. 2017 was clearly McDermott's draft. While Monos and Whaley were still officially in their titles, McDermott selected the picks. Whaley was fired immediately after the 2017 draft, and Monos was among the Bills staff who were let go by Beane after he was hired as GM. Sean McDermott's first and second round draft picks: 2017: #27 DB Tre'Davious White, #37 WR Zay Jones, #63 LT Dion Dawkins In 2017, White was 2nd in DROY voting. In 2019, White was first team All Pro and 5th in DPOY voting. In 2020, he was 2nd team All Pro. From 2021 through 2024, Dawkins was been named to the PB 4 times. Beane's first and second round draft picks: 2018 - #7 QB Josh Allen, #16 LB Tremaine Edmunds 2019 - #9 DT Ed Oliver, #38 OG Cody Ford 2020 -#54 DE AJ Epenesa 2021 - #30 DE Gregory Rousseau, #61 LB Boogie Basham 2022 - #23 CB Kaiir Elam, #63 RB James Cook In 2024, after numerous PB and AP awards, Allen was named NFL MVP. In 2019 and 2020, Edmunds was named to the PB. In 2023 and 2024, Cook was named to the PB. He also ran for 1000+ yards in both seasons. He also scored 16 TDs in 2024. Of course, Monos is going to dump on Beane and McDermott. Bean and McDermott exposed the institutional incompentency of their predecessors.

I think we need to revive the old "beating a dead horse" emogi for threads like this. Guess what, guys, dolls, and whomever else keeps beating this dead horse: the Bills are not moving on from McDermott until/unless the Bills have multiple losing seasons or repeatedly miss the playoffs without some valid excuse such as a serious injury to Allen. If the Bills lost in the WC round multiple times in a row, that might motivate Pegula to seek a new coach, but I can't see him moving on from McDermott otherwise. Why would he? He's a relative newcomer to the NFL owners' club and he's got one of the best teams in the NFL. Better than any of his AFCE rivals. Better than legendary NFL franchises like the Steelers and the Cowboys. He's not moving on from McDermott until he's dissatisfied with McDermott no matter how much some anonymous fans on a message board complain.

Since the Bills are limited by the cap, they can either pursue a game wrecking DLer or an elite WR in FA. They can't get both. I'd prioritize the DE and look for a good WR prospect in the draft and/or re-signing Cooper at a reasonable price. A great DE like Garrett would positively affect the entire DL, and a better pass rush would also help the DBs. Trying to outscore other playoff teams in a run to the Super Bowl requires your offense to execute almost perfectly game after game after game. That's an almost impossible task. A fierce pass rush affects the QB even if it only gets pressure rather than sacks ... incompletes, interceptions, and bad decisions.

1 game is a very small sample size, dude. Pressuring/sacking elite QBs frequently reduces them to ordinary QBs, especially in the playoffs. In this year's playoffs alone, the Bills D got after Lamar alot ... and the Bills won. The Bills D couldn't pressure Mahomes in the AFCCG, and KC won. In the Super Bowl, the Eagles harassed Mahomes while the game was in doubt -- and Mahomes played more like Mitch Trubisky.

What you are missing is that great QBs help any WR with a modicum of talent far more than a great WR can help a great QB. It's different with young or less talented QBs, but Allen is a great veteran. He can get by without having a world-class speed WR. What a great QB needs most is protection and weapons, and an OL that is great at pass and run blocking is the more important of the two because it makes a great running game possible. The exact nature of the weapons on passing plays -- WRs, TEs or RBs -- doesn't matter much if they do different things. A reasonably good boundary WR like Cooper is fine for the Bills as they are currently constructed. A better (ie, more expensive) WR like Higgins would be a luxury. Your narrative isn't correct. It's not like the Bills haven't tried to draft a game wrecker DLer. They drafted 4 DLers in rounds 1 and 2 between 2019 and 2021. DT Ed Oliver at #9 in 2019 DE AJ Epenesa in #54 in 2020 DE Gregory Rousseau at #30 and DE Boogie Basham at #61 in 2021 Basham was a bust, but Oliver and Rousseau are both good DLers and Epenesa is decent. Where the Bills draft at the end of rounds, the fail rate for draft picks is greater than 50%. it's hard to find many great pass rushers there because most pass rushers are gobbled up in the top ten spots of most drafts. I would love for the Bills to keep Cook, but if it comes down to acquiring a game wrecker DE and letting Cook walk, then it's "C'ya, Jimbo".

The 2002 Bills had a QB who had started in the Super Bowl, Drew Bledsoe. He made the Pro Bowl that season because he threw for more than 4300 yards and 24 TDs despite being sacked 54 times. Unfortunately, the Bills didn't have a defense. It ranked 27th despite having Nate Clemens, London Fletcher, Pat Williams, and Antoine Winfield SR on the roster. Bledsoe threw for nearly 3000 yards and 20 TDs. With Willis McGahey at RB, the Bills offense ranked #7. The 2004 Bills again had no defense -- they ranked 25th-- despite having Sam Adams, Nate Clemens, London Fletcher, Takeo Spikes, and Pat Williams. In the final game of the year, the Bills blew their chance at the playoffs by losing to the Steelers' backups, 29-24, and it wasn't really that close. They allowed UDFA rookie Willie Parker to run for 102 yards on 19 carries. Josh Allen would have been a bust if he had been on any of the teams fielded by the Bills during Jauron's stint as HC. He would have been benched for Captain Check Down, Trent Edwards, because Allen would have tried too hard to win games. Jauron's aim was always to not lose by too much.

Allen wouldn't have played as well as he did in 2022 behind that 2014 OL. It was significantly worse than the Bills 2022 OL.

If the Bills have a young LB already on the roster or if they draft a kid to replace him in 2025, then I have no problem with letting him leave in 2026. Since the Bills D obviously needs improvement, I'd be against letting Bernard walk without his replacement being on the roster. He's a good LB despite his size. Once a player proves himself to be a top level player, his draft round means nothing. Benford is an excellent DB, and it's a premium position. I am more concerned about his concussions.

Like most of the Bills rosters during the Drought era, the 2014 team was good on only one side of the ball with almost all the resources on the defense. The OL was trash. There is no way that Allen would be nearly as successful behind the crappy OL whose best player, Eric Wood, was an average Center at best. He might make the current roster as a back up, but I doubt that any of the others could make the current Bills. Freddie Jackson, the Bills featured RB in 2014, would likely not even make the Bills roster. Sammy Watkins and Robert Woods were decent WRs but not sinificantly better than Cooper/Hollins and Shakir. On defense, the strength was clearly the DL with Mario Williams(AP), Kyle Williams (PB), Marcel Dareus (AP), and Jerry Hughes. The LBs were ok and the DBs inlcuded 2 good ones (Stephon Gilmore and Aaron Williams) and two JAGs.

Wrong again, dude. I was a season ticket holder during part of the Drought. Most of those seasons, the best part of Bills games was the tailgating. So, what were those "3-4 teams that would've been legitimate SB contenders" that had "more talent than we have now"?

In what alternative universe did these Drought era "rosters that were better than the current Bills one, but simply lacked the QB" exist?

I totally agree. A side benefit of having an outstanding OL and WRs willing to block is that RBs are much easier to replace because they have holes to run through.