PrimeTime101

yep... Beane is going to "chase" RB's in the draft again!! We are now done with RB starters and Depth. Next position please? RT.

Kumerow 2.0

I am going to simplify this but with a Twist. How about this one... Every player that was given a position on our offensive line that did not have to compete for the Job. I am sure you can think of a lot of names here. ...

This comment lacks knowledge and adds just plain stupid to the conversation. McD. was not a HC in Carolina nor did he have anything close to a last say of what their picks would be. McD was a DC in Carolina during the years of 2011-2016. 2011 Carolina got a dude named Cam Newton. 2012 they got Luke Kuechly. So they get their QB on each side of the field like we did... During this time, they had the team set up for running so their Offensive line was already good. In Short... to poster child McD and his habits as a DC going back to Carolina is silly. How much of a say as DC do you think McD had on the offensive side of the field instead of defense in his years as DC in Carolina? just stop..

I think we replace with a slower "smarter" vet that maybe reads plays better than Edmunds did...

I just feel frustrated on this topic cause I got harassed on this same thing last year and now that its turned, its like "well why didn't we do this or that" frustrating. sorry about caps.

No.. OMG we been over this 1000 times on these forums.

Just to be Clear, The middle of the field was WIDE OPEN that playoff game. That is by play calling, scheme and having your players in the right position to make a play. I am not saying Poyer and Edmunds are the best in the league... what I am saying is due to scheme, those guys were not in the right places all the time. So I go 50/50 not just cause of scheme. And I stand by that.

Its not hindsight when SOME of us wanted an extension bigger then the 1 year rookie extension. Some of us slammed for wanting a bigger contract last year and now you call it hindsight? how very convenient

when they extended him. They specifically said "we will give him his 5th year and talks about contract extensions that year"

I am really tired of hearing this narrative that because Milano played great that they chose Milano over Edmunds... Extending Milana was cheaper than keeping Edmunds... THATS why they Edmunds is gone. My personal opinion is that Edmunds looked bad at times do to scheme more then play. The old theory is... put the players in the right place to do well... And I thought at times, Edmunds was way out of position and because of this... it allowed Edmunds to bite on plays he never would of bit on. Scheme screwed this team this year... Middle of the field was open what felt like all year long and we never adjusted... Cinci saw it and took advantage.

There are just some things we cant do without an Edmunds.. Just putting that out there. Cover 1 also made this very clear that without an Edmunds our scheme will change... though I think most of us are just fine with that fact as well

it was said specifically that there were no contract extension talks other than picking up his 5th year.

Your going about this wrong River... Did you see anything that would suggest he did NOT want to be extended? To that answer no. and to your original answer? Why would he not want to be extended? players want to get paid.

Last year and this time of year, I got roasted for suggesting extending Edmund's contract then because IF Edmunds had a really good year... we would not of been able to afford him. Imagine that,,, Now he had one of his best seasons, his contract numbers go up and the same people regret not extending him last year... Just annoying to me and that's why this topic gets my anger face...

ha ha ha now FIX IT!!!!!

Lies ALL LIES I TELL YOU thanks for the reply

I DONT normally do this man... IT just disgusts me

nothing but Agree.

@Reed83HOF I sure would like to know why you put a thumbs down on this thread... This is nothing but good news.

Thanks for letting us all know SDS. This is great news. ****Requesting this topic be a sticky for a couple days for all to see****

your wearing off on me

yea? there was a farewell days before the last game.

dont you ever stop? lol Take that energizer bunny out of your ass and relax man. lol