He's above average as of now, but just wait till a game is on the line and we need that FG to win it (i'm not counting the wide right against KC last year in the playoffs, as we don't know if the FG would even have won us the game.......13 seconds fiasco comes to mind).
The kicker has one job.....one job, that's it and if you can't rely 100% on him to do that job, then you look elsewhere and the fact that our FO didn't even consider looking at any other kickers in the off season (i'm assuming here) is disgusting.
If it were up to me, i would remove all kicking of any sort out of the game......punts, extra points, FG's, etc......outta here.