BananaB

Dude he’s inconsistent catching every type of pass it got nothing to do with length of route.

Everyone knows Davis gets yardage. He makes big plays. Problem is he is very inconsistent in between the big plays. We need a guy who is reliable to help move the chains, not just produce on deep routes.

Was the run play with Gabe telegraphed? 😂

If the guys can’t be trusted to make a play you can’t keep throwing it deep. The second pass the Gabe was on 3rd and 20 and the INT switched the field possession. It’s a very low risk throw. To be honest if Gabe didn’t drop the pass thrown to him before that, which was a pretty easy catch we would not of been in that position

I think part of it is the talent level behind Diggs and how teams are playing us. McD and Dorsey stressing on it because pushing the ball downfield with inconsistent players will lead to more turnovers. Josh gotta be a surgeon out there pretty much all the time. Maybe someone will step up as the year goes on.

I think we’re at a point like late in the season last year except we are really starting to work underneath instead mid to long range. It looks off because that’s not who Allen is and at this point he’s kind of forced to do it. The hype this off-season was how much better we were with Harty, Sherfield and Kincaid but none of them have made a big impact. Kincaid seems reliable but not getting the looks we expected after hearing Beane say he was Cole Beasley at TE. Harty looks worse the Lil Dirty out there. Sherfield is a ghost most of the time.

Gabe is Gabe… 2 catches, 6 catches and 1 catch. The inconsistencies are not improving. We need a more reliable player in that #2 spot.

Hardy is just a gadget player, it’s no coincidence they cut McKenzie the day after. They thought they were getting an upgrade but it’s really not looking like it at this point. McKenzie was terrible out of the slot, but he did pretty good for a while on alot of this gadget plays. At this point I don’t think we need to be forcing gadget plays and would like to see more of Shakir and Sherfield. Just seems like we’re always going backwards when Dorsey tries to be cute

Diggs ain’t really a yac guy and Davis ain’t getting yac unless he gets behind defenders. The rest we really ain’t sure about. Seems like they are trying to set up Harty but are unsuccessful. Do teams that get a lot of yac spread the ball around to bunch of different WRs, or is it certain guys get all those yards. Harty, Sherfield and Shakir seem to be the guys who might be able to make an impact there but they aren’t getting many looks and they are all a bit different so it makes it harder to get in rhythm with Allen.

Why we running out of shotgun on third and short

Did he say he thought Josh played good last week despite two throws? But Dan Orlovsky said he was basically a mess. Who should I believe? 🤷🏼‍♂️

Opportunity in more situations outside the redzone. That’s who we are though and it makes it alittle obvious. We done it with Singletary/Gore, Singletary/Moss and Cook/Harris/Murray. He was the short yardage guy they leaned on. It’s harder when teams know what your doing too

Wasn’t Jacobs on the sidelines? Why was he out there trying to pad his stats? Guys that are backups are looking to prove themselves not give some diva a free ride to the endzone.

Most of the nation don’t realize the Phins beat the Bills once since Josh’s rookie year and we had players dropping like flies because heat exhaustion. I think we’re at a point until they do it regularly they can’t be placed higher.

Nothings really changed. Especially not with a win over the Raiders. See how the season ends for me. We could win 12 and have another heart breaking finish in playoffs

It’s funny I was just reading on the Elam inactive thread that we are lucky to have such depth

He might know defense but their is a problem with scouting if guys we draft high never really help us

McD can’t get quality play out of any draft pick. Boogie, Aj and now Elam. Wasting picks. We were lucky Benford stepped up, sadly we had to go pay veterans to rush the passer. Trust the process

Until the WRs prove themselves you can’t say they’re fine. Gabe has proven to be inconsistent, adding someone we know we can rely on would probably helped him.

How about shortly after our proven players left and we started gambling with our WRs outside of Diggs. Beas, Sanders and Brown were all proven, we knew what we’d get out of them and for the most part they were easily trusted. I understand Gabe and McKenzie deserved a shot but it didn’t worked out as expected. You think it would be lesson learned. Then instead of trying to grab guys we know can help we gambled on other guys and doubled down on Gabe. To be honest I’d rather a player who done it consistently before and another late round draft pick on the roster the Sherfield and Harty. Adding a 5’6 WR who might just be a gadget guy seems to be a luxury addition if you don’t have many problems. Kind of like trading for an undersized RB mid season when it’s obvious you need a bruiser.

Last year in December we had to sign two WRs Josh was comfortable with because lack of trust in supporting cast. It was as an unusual situation but it highlighted problems. Beane just never did enough to fix it.

Gabe shows up small almost every week

One game doesn’t determine who you are.

I meant it in a way that we only had 4 suited up on Sundays.

30% in what situations? We ran 4 WRs most of the year that’s a slim depth chart. He’s gonna see the field doesn’t mean he’s gonna get an equal opportunity to see the ball. We also had problem catching last year and the Giants stole a guy who’s biggest strength in college was his hands. Oddly enough he made an impact while giving an opportunity in NY. Never got that opportunity here because our WR group was deep. Lmfao! Try to explain that to me