CuddyDark

I wouldn't hate it. I don't think he becomes a star but take the shot, why not?

Outside the top ten is always less value.

Most seem to believe Darnold is going #1. He's probably the least ready to start of the top 3 but he has the greatest upside projection.

I could see it.

Mayfield has the least amount of fixing needed. He's got the best accuracy. He wins. He leads. He hates his rivals. He takes football seriously. He's clearly the best QB IMO. He's "short" so he's not seen as a potential franchise QB.

Personally I believe he'll go to the Giants. 1. Darnold 2. Mayfield 3. Rosen 4. Barkley 5. Chubb 6. Nelson 7. Fitzpatrick

It's all entertainment. No sports new there. They'll bring on anything if it fits their narrative.

WGR is an entertainment show. No real sports new there.

His guess is as good as anybody's but if this happens it will most likely be 12, 22, 53, 56 + 2nd in 2019.

It could. The other 3 have played against NFL players though.

I agree they need to take a shot. It is Buffalo tho and risk takers don't last long here. I personally would be willing to give McDermott two or three shots at the QB position. We do know how the radio drives narratives here tho.

He doesn't need to be rebuilt. It's all level of comp and reading defenses. That could take 3 years to develop, however.

But it would build the exact offence their OC had in Pitt. Big QB and franchise RB. The offense they run both the OC and the HC is power running and over the top long ball. Allen and Barkley would be perfect for them.

I think it's a bad trade. JMO.

Why would they move when they could take Barkley at 4? Not true. They had to rebuild his entire throwing motion.

That would be a bad trade for the Giants. The cost will be at least four picks in the first 2 rounds.

Trade up to 1 and take Allen. Damn. IDK how I'd feel about it.

They traded up for A quarterback. It is yet to be known if he will be a franchise QB.

They will. Only way they start a rookie game 1 is if its Jackson.

If you have a win now mentality take Jackson. In a three to five year window Jackson is most likely to win now.

Big Ben has a great arm though?

Book on him is simplest of the top four. He's a good player. Not great. Negligible star potential. Most likely to have a long unassuming career. Matt Ryan/Phillip Rivers ceiling. That all his good stuff. His bad makes him a gamble. Not a leader. Won't carry team on his back. Might not be willing to go extra mile. Varied interest outside football. Flaky personality. Might be sulky. Willis McGhee lifestyle.

I'd be in if we could take Roquan @12 someone else at 22 and trade back into 27-32 and take Rudolph.

Brady is a better leader and makes less poor reads, but I'll agree that Ryan is a lesser form of Brady.

No. Matt Schaub. No. Matt Ryan.