Jump to content

ClemsonBills

Community Member
  • Posts

    293
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ClemsonBills

  1. 1 hour ago, dave mcbride said:

    He is a first round talent. Who have the Bills drafted in the first round since Josh Allen who is better than him? The only upper echelon receiver they’ve had in this era was obtained by trading a first round pick.

    He is one more concussion away from retirement. He contemplated it last year. The Saints would immediately take that with zero counter. That is how bad that offer would be.

    • Like (+1) 1
  2. 16 hours ago, Low Positive said:

    But it made no sense. The only similarity between McDermott's defenses in Carolina and Frazier's defense is that they were both 4-3. McDermott had an attacking 4-3 in Carolina. He comes from the Jim Johnson/Eagles coaching tree, along with Spags. Frazier is a Tampa/Cover 2 zone guy who comes out of the Tony Dungy coaching tree. The "soft zone" that everyone here hates actually went out the door with Frazier. But that narrative was formed, and people think every defensive failure is due to it.

    But we watch corners play off the ball 10 yards constantly. Just because he came from that, doesn't mean that's what he still uses. I also agree that its a weak narrative, but shoot we all watch the games and can see how they are trying to scheme/attack. If he doesn't have the personnel to run what he wants, maybe there is a greater issue?

     

    If you need great personnel and very smart defensive players, how good is your defensive scheme? If you lose a key player in the playoffs and never force a punt, how good are you as a defensive coach? I am sick of McDermott getting a free pass, figure it TF out. Or fire another DC and think that'll fix it.

    • Eyeroll 1
    • Thank you (+1) 1
  3. On 5/15/2025 at 12:15 AM, Mikie2times said:

    I think this is more the million dollar question. I have posted on this previously, below is the allocation of draft capitol by position. It's only looking at how teams spent what they had, not how much they had. I'm summing the total point value of every pick and looking at a % of how those point values were spent at each position. 

     

    Buffalo ranks 7th in defensive spend since 2018. We have had top 10 defenses in years past. We even had top 3 defenses in years past. It just doesn't translate when it matters most. Which speaks to your call out of philosophical changes. It is entirely possible Beane and McDermott could be highly effective leaders and that is most likely the case, but is our approach married to the wrong concepts, specifically on defense? Then if so, how likely is that to fundamentally change? More clarity should come this season I would think and that is part of what makes this year very exciting. 

     

    image.thumb.png.2371fc2e7e99faa489c6cd53de322a6e.png

     

    How do I get Beane and McDermott to read this?!

  4. 5 hours ago, BigDingus said:

     

    Please no...

     

    I ask all of you to think "what would an upgrade at safety really accomplish in McDermott's D?" Wouldn't we all say prime Micah Hyde & Jordan Poyer were a big upgrade over what we have now? And what did that look like come playoff time?

     

    Just remember, it's still McDermott's D. The point is that we could get 2 x studs back there, and the end result doesn't change the way he calls a game. I'm not saying it's ENTIRELY pointless, it's just the move least likely to help this team take a big step forward. I don't think having 2 great safeties back there will turn the tides against the Chiefs.

     

    I'd rather double down on our biggest strength - Josh Allen. The side of the ball most likely to see changes year-to-year is offense, so give Joe Brady more tools to help Josh succeed. McDermott & Beane are good at finding defensive talent in the later rounds anyway.

    this times a million

  5. 4 hours ago, zow2 said:

    I’m sure he feels like crap. Two seasons in a row, the offense has the ball in their hands at the end to tie or lead, and gets nothing. 

     

    Two end of game drives vs KC for all the marbles, Zero points.  You aren’t going to the SB with that.

    unless you have a defense like the ravens or chiefs

  6. 26 minutes ago, BuffaloBill said:

    This is wayyyy …. overstated. I think there is room for a reasonable second contract.  However, to your point his skill set is limited and he is not good at pass pro. I just don’t see him getting a huge contract given the short half life of RB’s in the NFL.

    Some team will overpay to the point where the Bills will not match. The cap is going up and struggling teams typically overpay for skill position players. The Bills are smart and will continue to draft RBs (see Ray Davis). They will not sign a RB to a second year contract of any significant value with Josh Allen on the books. 

    • Agree 1
×
×
  • Create New...