Kind of hard to judge the QB's success when Manning and Brady have done what they've done. I really think you can argue about 4 GOATs at QB and 3 of them happened to play at the same time (Rodgers). Can I really fault Rivers for not consistently besting the Patriots? Or any NFC team in their QBs (Ryan, Brees, Stafford, Rodgers, Newton, Romo, Wilson). It is tough. Wilson and Brady weren't amazing QBs until after the first few years.