After the draft, and his first season, I had been optimistic that Josh could be really good "someday"...that they could coach out his worst habits, add a surrounding cast in the receiver corps; o-line etc, and maybe he could rise to his potential, which was clearly there. But lots of young QB's have potential that never consistently develops, so you never know.
Then the T'giving game vs. Dallas happened. I have never doubted his draft selection since that game.