I feel sort of the same way as the OP. I feel a lot more confident in Beane than McD. Beane is smart, and seems to have a vision...and he admits mistakes.
I haven’t completely given up on McD, but it’s hard to have faith. I don’t care about the clapping or comments about watching tape. I care about how many times we’ve been blown out, and have looked completely unprepared. I care about some of the stupid and repetitive mistakes that this team seems to make every game - that kind of lack of discipline is a reflection of coaching.
I just don’t see it. Every other game, we seem to have a decent enough defensive game plan, but it falls apart quickly. And the offense is such a shambles.