Scott7975

This is how I feel too. Josh has to be superman because Gabe isn't good enough. I like Gabe, but I think we can do better. I also don't think he is worth paying a high contract to. He doesn't have speed, doesn't separate except for maybe busted coverage on a super long route, he isn't good at contested balls, he isn't good at running routes. He is a decent receiver, but we need to do better. He is just too 50/50. Either he is a drive saver or a drive killer. Sometimes that can be a game killer. Honestly Knox is kinda the same way. He has drive killing drops too often as well.

I agreed somewhat with your thread but this I don't agree with. McD isn't conservative and I don't think he is holding Josh back. The only thing McD wants to that effect is for Josh to be smart and slide or get out of bounds when he runs and for Josh to make better decisions than throwing into double coverage when he doesn't have to. Otherwise I think McD wants Josh to lead a high powered offense. He may want some run game so the opposing D can't pin their ears back but thats just smart.

Josh leaps defenders Wilkens likes grabbing privates Tua gets concussed

I think it’s really the misdirection with their motions that cause problems with their run game coupled with the speed. McD is a dork but a really smart HC.

Yes there are a lot of bad QBs that is for sure. I think he got done wrong but after suing and this amount of time out of the league there is about zero chance he gets hired.

Well if the "punching bag" is a weakness of a team then people are going to talk about it. Why is it a problem to talk about a weak player?

It's just discussing a weakness on the team.

I think he means over Zach Wilson.

This dude is not a very good QB. He isn't terrible but he isn't very good either. He sued the NFL and reached a settlement with them. Not many people sue their employers and still work for them. Nobody is going to hire this dude. It's time he gives up.

I'm glad someone else gets this. Our passing game is affected by this. Mostly the TE's. By the time they get in their route, Josh has already moved on the read. The routes just take too long when we got two extra people trying to help Brown out. Brown is doing ok with the help. Once he is in position, he usually holds the block pretty well. He is just too slow to get in position. Our passing game would be so much better if he didn't need the help all the time. Dorsey could also get some better route designs though. Some of them take way too long. Others, I am not sure if its him or receivers running bad routes but I see plays almost every game where at least two receivers are in the same area. This stems back to last year too.

But but but he is just doing what the D coordinator asks him to. He gets no stats because no one throws his way. Except when that receiver runs right past him and he just stands there of course.

You need to get good middle penetration to make him look and move.

Yup, the overuse of shotgun needs to go. Undercenter Josh is better. Playaction Josh is better. Under center run game is better. How is Dorsey the only one who doesn't see this.

Nobody wants to play there. All the other vets declined.

Finally, someone understands this. I was talking about Brown in the Collins thread. People telling me Brown is fine and I'm bashing him. I try to point out that he isn't fine and that he is getting a lot of help. I'm then told every right tackle gets help. I said it's limiting our passing game. I was then told I am bashing and that Brown is playing very well. Just smh.

He did tap him there. It doesn't matter how hard it was. It was disrespectful dirty *****. How about I come lightly tap you there and watch for your reaction. I bet you wouldn't like it.

I honestly don't think he will be active. I think he should be and then put him in IF we are having problems. I dunno that he needs to shadow because Waddle has speed too. Having speed out there should be able to at least comfortably take one away.

Might be the weakest attempt I have seen. Par for course of this game I guess.

Bengals had like 8 bounces their way. Time for Rams to get one bounce their way lol. Won't happen but would make a boring game a little more fun.

They didnt even audible run against 3 man front on short yardage to get the first

Dudes aren't even trying to get out of bounds

Rams made themselves one dimensional. Refused to run the ball even when the score was close. And their run game was working. McVay may be some genius but he's an idiot.

Wow stafford just fell. He coulda at least threw the ball away

I said just before the Bengals drive that the Rams should run the ball once in a while. Bengals run the ball and score a TD. Rams pass the ball, get a big play, then proceed to throw an INT. I don't get it. They CAN run the football but refuse to.