This is a sad,sad thing. You announced the Listenbee pick and you have NEVER BEEN TO BUFFALO?! You must, immediately, remedy this situation.
In terms of the food, the reports of excellent pizza are true, but Wings and beef on weck are the cuisine WNY is most known for. As such, there are a lot of places that do them well as a source of pride...and tourist dollars. Pizza, like most all North American cities, is a staple of diet in Buffalo. And, like most all North American cities, there are a number of restaurants that excel in making great pizza.