Interestingly enough, that's actually not true. We, as a group, have generally liked players that have turned out to be good. A few notables were being essentially unanimously against Maybin and preferring Orakpo, skipping EJ for anyone, and trading up for Khalil Mack not Sammy.
We don't get diamonds in the rough right, usually our late round envy is for media hyped guys, like Griffin, etc.