oldmanfan

Cool

Just seemed an odd way to state it; I thought he had his best game today.

1. Our young QB and young MLB showed promise but also that they have a lot to learn. I think they each have the drive to do that and become fixtures on each side of the ball. 2. Defense looked good overall. We still need a true edge rush guy or more disruptive DT. Hope we get one in the draft. 3. We need to rebuild a lot of the O line. Dawkins is the only guy who should be ensured of a job next year. This should be a prime target for FAs. 4. Make Shady a third down specialist, and find a one cut and go guy. 5. Need a couple WRs, but Foster and Jones are keepers. 6. Need a new O line coach and special teams coach. 7. McD should overhaul his process for play challenges.

As long as he gets down and slides quicker no reason to take the run game away from him

Your first sentence you said he seemed like the same old Josh. How can that be if he had his best game? I do agree he needs to work on his slant patterns, and the pick was a classic rookie misread.

I thinkRosen will be around for quite a while. And so will Allen

Silly me

I would say no. And I base that on living outside Indy and reading about Manning. Manning practiced a lot with his WRs and demanded precise patterns. If you were running a 10 yard out it better be 10 and not 11 because he was throwing it to the 10 yard mark. I think Brady is even more demanding. I was watching several games with playoff implications after the Bills game. Have to say I saw a lot of errant throws from a lot of guys.

He missed a few today. He's missed a few every game. I'd love to sit with you next season and chart throws together and see how close we agree. I mentioned above I wonder what the inter and intraobserver variance is in all these analyses.

The kid has work to do in the passing game but his ability to run like that adds a dimension others just don't have

Throw Alonzo out of the league. Does this crap all the time

Shady needs to be a third down back

Good response after the pick 6

Good throw and catch

Agree with Beurlein. Allen has to be pushed this off season on those short throws.

Rookie mistake. Snookered by a veteran DB

That doesn't look good for Tre

Add a punter to the offseason list.

Rookie QB mistake. Makes it exciting though

Not a very good pass but finally a WR makes a tough catch!

I hate in when he throws back into the middle of the field. Worked there though

Go back and read then. It's ignorant to argue when you have not even read what I and others have written about the potential problems with the PFF analysis.

Why don't you for once stop with your nonsense? No one is saying the kid has arrived. He obviously has more to learn and more to improve on, and any cursory view of posts around here will show that. What people do see though is the potential to become the guy. When the only thing you can do is to deliberately lie about what people say it shows your ignorance. Yes. Go back and read what I and others have discussed about the difficulties in such analyses. But you won't because you have what is called confirmation bias. You want Allen to fail therefore anything that says he will you suck up to and anything that challenges it you won't read. Just as well; you likely wouldn't be able to understand it anyway.

No one set the edge all game long

Yes I did and have commented on it extensively herein as to the difficulties in such analyses. Some of us don't blindly take numbers someone throws out there to support a set conviction as you have done.