Jump to content

Buffalo716

Community Member
  • Posts

    19,352
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Buffalo716

  1. 3 minutes ago, Sammy Watkins' Rib said:

     

    I agree he is a future HOFer but disagree with the thinking he had a WOW season for us. It is possible for HOF RB's to only have one WOW type season and make the HOF. Look at Frank Gore's stats. Another future HOFer. 

     

    Some players get in on having many wow type seasons in a short career while other get in on longevity and consistency. The latter has been more of McCoy's route to the HOF.

     

    You act like there are a lot of schlubbs in the HoF at RB

     

    there are only like 26 or 27 modern backs in... Terrell Davis is like the only disputed guy with a really short career

     

    McCoy is a better RB than Frank Gore

  2. 2 minutes ago, Sammy Watkins' Rib said:

     

    Not when he doesn't even total 1300 rushing yards. A wow season was his 2013 season when he went over 2100 yards from scrimmage.

     

    By that standard he has pretty much1 wow season...

     

    because it was easily his 3rd best season ever and not far off from his 2nd best

     

    He is a HoF and we got his 3rd best season ever. I'd say that's wow enough 

     

     

  3. 11 minutes ago, Sammy Watkins' Rib said:

    McCoy has yet to have a "WOW" type of season in his 3 years with us. I don't believe there is any official criteria for making the WOF but I think he needs at least another two solid seasons of production with us like he has had in his first three. 

     

    Leading the NFL in YPC in 2016 isn't a wow season ?

  4. Just now, CountDorkula said:

    Because currently the majority of his career and success was spent in Philly, and He is still known for his days as an Eagle.

     

    If he plays 2 more years here... he would have spent 5 years here and 6 in Philly...

     

    not too mention getting 10k here and probably 12 k...

     

    he is on the right track ... he is a Bill now, not an Eagle

  5. 27 minutes ago, Jay_Fixit said:

    I don’t care.

     

    How much Rosen have you watched? Because it sounds like it isn’t much.

     

     

     

    I have watched every game from his true freshmen year. And a few from his junior year. (USC, A&M, Memphis and Oregon) 

     

    i will watch every game

     

    And I never said he is a perfect prospect by any means ... but he has a lot of things that coaches would love to work with

     

    his durability concerns may be real... he will need to get bigger 

    • Like (+1) 2
  6. 20 minutes ago, Jay_Fixit said:

    So did I. 

     

    Question...how much Rosen have you watched? Not just from searching through Twitter/Youtube/Etc? 

     

    Dude,  I am fortunate enough to be employed in the game of football.

     

    all I do is watch football 

    • Like (+1) 1
  7. 2 minutes ago, Jay_Fixit said:

    Because I’m smart. That’s why.  And I never said I don’t understand it. 

     

    I understand what people think it means. It’s not quantifiable. And I’m going by what you think it means and Rosen doesn’t have as much as you think he does.

     

     

     

    We will see.

     

    he certainly doesn't lack it ...

     

    and I know what it means. I grew up on a football field 

  8. 1 hour ago, Jay_Fixit said:

    He looks every bit the part of a franchise QB. From afar.

     

    However, his “football IQ” isn’t that good. Whatever that even means.

     

     

     

    If you don't understand what football IQ is how can you comment on it?

     

    https://www.google.com/amp/s/gojoebruin.com/2018/01/10/ucla-football-trent-dilfer-gives-support-josh-rosen/amp/

     

    here is trent dilfer saying he is very intellectual and at the end of the article high football IQ is mentioned 

     

    and Dilfer has been very hard on him over the years going back to elite 11

  9. Just now, CritMark said:

     

    If anyone has been a football fan for any length of time you know there are no sure things.  No one measure is always 'the best way' to evaluate a kid coming out of collage and projecting their success in the NFL. 

     

    Rosen is bright, has superior mechanics and has some questions.

     

    Darnold has a big arm, has played some great games and has some questions.

     

    Mayfield's stats are off the charts, intensely passionate, throws receivers open and has questions.

     

    Allen has all the measurable but can't hit a net from 10 yards away (sorry I couldn't resist) and has questions.

     

    Every evaluator has to decide which combination of attributes and flaws will yield them the best result.  If I could hand place each of these guys on a team with a specific scenario I think they would all be successful.  But they go where they get drafted and the best players go to the worst teams by design.  Sometime that works out and sometimes it fails miserably.

     

    I think Rosen would do very poorly in Cleveland and very well with the Giants.  Bottom line "can be" is accurate, will be is quite another story.   Let's see where he ends up first.

     

    Definitely. I believe i said can be as well...

     

    None of these guys are cant miss... the NFL has always been about the situation you are I 

  10. 22 minutes ago, SouthNYfan said:

     

    Darnold is about 220lbs.

    Rodgers was 224@ combine I think.

    Ben was 240+@combine.

    He's more comparable to Rodgers size, but I do agree about the arm and style being more comparable to Ben

     

    "Sources out west" "dialed in at USC"

     

    Stahp.

     

     

    Yea I know he said not Big Ben weight ...

     

    i was just comparing playing style and I see a lot of similarities 

    • Like (+1) 1
×
×
  • Create New...