No, I understood you completely. Even if Beane believes Rudolph to be THE GUY, he'd be a fool to move up to 2 to take him. An absolute fool. Why?
Because Rudolph can be had at 22..certainly at 12. And I'll bet you that he could even be had in the 2nd round.
You don't move up when you grade a guy as drastically better than everyone else does...you move down, collect some extra picks, and still get your guy.
Learn something about what you're talking about before you get all snippy, Gomer.