SouthNYfan

I'm pretty sure that just being out of gas would be an improvement. He looks like the car is completely totaled.

My buddy is a giants fan too. He's not happy. He wanted Chubb or a QB long term.

Shurm was actually a big Webb fan on college, wanted the Vikings to draft him, and was excited to get to work with him on the Giants, from what I've heard. The fact that he decided to cut bait on him, even with all that going for him, is very telling. The dude sucks.

That's right. 1 reception on 10 targets is what matters at the end of the day. Since other things were being brought into the discussion, I decided to use the negative things he did as well as a counterpoint.

I am concerned that he's pining for him based on his familiarity with him Look what it did for Chip Kelly when he gutted the eagles going after Oregon players It's not a good way to run a team if you're using that for decisions over other things like talent So it's just s concern

Yeah, basically speed and daboll. Oh well. I think he sucks. Let's hope he can turn it around.

Agreed Even if they were out of bounds though, I didn't see him even make an effort to be on bounds, ie he wasn't even aware of where the sideline was. Maybe he can learn? I feel like ball tracking and field awareness are difficult to teach though.

How about him not tracking the sideline and making an effort to get his feet in on any of those? How about not making an effort for that one deep ball that he clearly could have gotten if he didn't give up on it?

Agreed. He's a very quick accelerator and very shifty, I think he'd be good on some reverses

Let me know when the NFL starts counting all those non-receptions. He's on the roster because he's fast and he's dabolls boy from Alabama. Ditto.

1 for 10. That's all that counts for him.

Which is absurd. I'm not interested in discussing balls a guy catches that aren't receptions. 1 reception on 10 targets.

He had 1 reception all preseason. What 4 catches are you referring to?

Yeah it's going to be tough. I mean if you're the bears and you think you're a SB contender for 2018-2022 then I get why they did it. Mack is legit elite and game changing. The issue is the draft picks PLUS the contract. If he's anything short of HoF caliber play for 4+ years straight then they got completely robbed. If they win a SB with him dominating though, nothing else matters. Bears get: Khalil Mack 2020 2nd round 2020 conditional 5th Raiders get: 2019 1st 2019 3rd 2020 1st 2020 6th

He made the team because of daboll. 'bama Bros cult stick together. He's been open all the time against third string dbs. Maybe they leave him open because he can't catch?? He's like featherstone in "necessary roughness"

Can we sample all their DNA and clone then into one wr?

I do agree with you there. I was okay with the price (7th round pick) and I at least thought they'd give him a shot to play in the reg season.

Bama only required a 900 SAT score for entry prior to 2016 (switched to ACT now) so yeah... really high bar to shoot for bro.

HAH. no thanks man. sounds more like you

Says the guy who thinks every Alabama player is going to be in the Hof. How is your prediction about mccarron being our starter going?

Foster making the team is idiotic. Cutting Coleman is idiotic. We basically just traded a 7th round pick for $3.5 of dead cap and didn't even give him more than a couple of weeks to adjust.

If he was the kind of backup teams love them why did we trade him?

Says the Alabama homer. Guess who makes billions per year with "no credibility"? ESPN. Guess who makes nothing off his zero credibility? You.

"McCarron has now blown through two teams in less than a calendar year. His extended playing time with the Buffalo Bills this preseason suggested he is the kind of backup you hope never gets onto the field." from ESPN article HAHAHA. http://www.espn.com/blog/nflnation/post/_/id/280586/biggest-surprises-and-takeaways-from-nfl-cutdown-day