JohnBonhamRocks

Just have him post up the middle linebacker like a power forward. Five yard catches all the way down the field.

Williams would be ideal, but remember reading a fairly recent article in which he made it clear he wants to go to a contender, and I don't think that's how the Bills are viewed. Would not be surprised or disappointed by a look at Hillman - he struggled last year, but was good with Dennison in Denver the year prior with 863 yards and 7 touchdowns. Plus, although last year was poor with 2.8 YPC, he's put up the following (YPC/year): 3.9/2012, 4.0/2013, 4.1/2014, 4.2/2015. History of production and scheme familiarity - there are worse tires to kick.

"But I dont see a top 5 secondary here."

4.9 YPC in 2015 aint that bad. Believe the Bucs Oline was in the bottom half of the league last year, so maybe our run blocking could help him return to form from his injury.

Not that I have reason to doubt Poyer, but I also don't have reason to know why I should like him, so he and the safety position are my biggest ?'s on D. Re: the 2017 defense as a whole, I'm fairly optimistic. The starting Dline should be average at very worst. Depth there could be better, but at least we have Worthy, Washington, and Davis. I'm not too worried about linebacker because, even if there aren't perfect scheme fits, we should be fine between Hodges, Brown, Ragland, Alexander, Humber, and the rookies (digression: wonder if they'll contribute at safety at all). That's a lot of bodies to rotate in, if nothing else, especially considering there will probably be only 2 on the field 60-70% of the time. While I don't think we have a shutdown corner, there appears to be a solid top 4 of Darby, White, Seymour, and Johnson. Even if the opposing WR1 isn't completely shut down, at least we'll be able to cover their WR1-3 decently well.

While I agree he's extremely important, I think having Dawkins take a bunch of reps at LT makes this loss a little more affordable in comparison with others.

The more you know that you don't know, the more you know. You know?

Top 5: 1. Taylor - the drop off from him to Yates is... not good 2. McCoy - bell-cow of the offense and do not want to see Williams as a HB1 3. Hyde - not sold on Poyer and Anderson seems more a special teamer than dependable safety 4. Hughes - okay with Lawson stepping in, but then Davis/Valles mans the other side 5. Watkins - almost did not make list because, like others said, used to his unavailability; still, Jones and Holmes is less than desirable

In totally unrelated news, a book burning has been announced in Buffalo this September.

No reason to think he can't at least compete with the likes of Philly Brown, Walt Powell, and Rashad Ross.

Safety. Optimistic, but unsold on Poyer.

While I also love this, how about we fill the potholes downtown to start?

Let's have fun with this: Green-Beckham-Sefarian-Jenkins-Smith-Shuster-Heyward-Bey-Green-Ellis Next?

What if he bends his knee and vows to trust the process?

"I need loyalty, I expect loyalty."

HC - Mularky (didn't quit on his team, closest we've been to playoffs) OC - Gailey (got production out of Fitzpatrick and Johnson; will call screens to Watkins) DC - Williams (certainly not Ryan, too bad Schwartz is not an option) ST - Lynn (seems to be a leader of men and can covertly call the offense)

Figured you had the NFC South information via NO. Unfortunately, not too confident anything done against the Saints defense is too great a marker in recent history. I'd like to think Williams can contribute more, but just did not see it last year. Given how good our line was at run blocking, his production did not seem all that great; 3.5 YPC is a little underwhelming considering our backs had 2.8 or so yards before contact on average. Hopefully he returns to more of what he showed in college. I can't say I have no hope for a HB going into his second season and who had a pretty major injury the year before. Definitely wish we kept Gillislee. Agree that we should have kept Gillislee, assuming you think that based on those numbers. While I don't expect him to give anywhere near Gillislee's output, Tolbert is 31 years old, not 33, and should contribute decently to our rushing attack. Sincere question: are you serious or sarcastic with the bolded statement? Would be very interested to know if he did lead the league in something.

Found the splits, and do not think they support what I said all that well. Also feel like they are missing some short-yardage situations, but I could just be misreading the numbers. Here, and you can go through his different years on the link: http://www.espn.com/nfl/player/splits/_/id/11658/mike-tolbert Before finding those numbers, I was going off the fact that he was listed as FB. Plus, I remember Fozzy Whittaker and Cameron Artis-Payne getting a decent amount of touches last year behind Jonathan Stewart, and the year prior they had DeAngelo Williams.

I would like to see him line up in a variety of places and his versatility utilized. If nothing else, he should allow Dennison to get a little creative and keep the defense off balance a bit. For example, if he's the shotgun single back on say, a 3rd and 4, then he could viably take a dive or draw hand-off, stay at home to block, or run a route. The defense has to account for all three. I hope he surprises. The low YPC and fumbles do concern me though, but here's to hoping!

I'll look and try to find some statistics on how many carries were short yardage, but am not sure where to find those (anyone else have suggestions?). As far as I can tell, he was listed as a fullback for the Panthers 2012-2016, as opposed to halfback for the Chargers 2008-2011. It's admittedly an assumption that his Panthers carries were short-yardage, but not a huge leap given that most fullback carries come in short-yardage situations, and he was a fullback his entire time there. That is part of my argument, but not the whole. I've mostly emphasized his versatility - can run, catch, and block - and leadership.

Having trouble locating - anyone have how much time the line gave Taylor to throw? I realize he affects this by choosing to throw or not throw, just looking for some statistics. The Dawkins pick seems like a real smart one at this point. Glenn has injury history. Incognito is no spring chicken. Mills has little business being a starter. Most definitely agree with the prior Cowher quote that investing in the OL is majorly important, and tend to have that view in general - that a team should build from the trenches on both sides of the ball. Glad we added to our OL depth.

There we go, some statistics. My facts were based on a quote from his coach in 2014, and also quotes from his current coach 3-4 months ago. I'm also having fun, and not offended - I just enjoy making arguments based on substance, like you finally did a little bit of with some statistics. Speaking of, he followed up the 2.1 YPC as a fullback with 4.1 (2015) and 3.3 (2016) YPC as a fullback. He had 3 and 1 receiving TDs in 2015 and 2016 as a fullback. Not amazing, but not terrible for a fullback who is probably only being asked to get 3-4 yards (goal line & 3rd/4th down conversions). Here, he will be used as a fullback and as a halfback. More chances to put up statistics. Even if he's not the one carrying the ball and scoring, I like that he can help McCoy stay fresh and by paving the way for him. And not even a huge Tolbert fan - I would have preferred we kept Gillislee (and maybe still have added Tolbert to compete with Williams for HB3). Not expecting him to be some team saving all pro running back taking the league by storm at 31 years old, but am interested to see how his versatility and leadership helps the Bills. But yeah, I'll enjoy my tenure, so long as you enjoy yours as the Cherry-Pick Facts & Resort to Insults Club (affiliates of the League of Poorly Crafted Arguments).

Attempts at insults are a common resort for people who cannot rely on facts. It happens more than it should on TBD. I hope your okay. Anyone want to talk football? Specifically the Buffalo Bills running back depth?

Favorite answer in the thread. Also, Alphadawg7, stop making sense!

Right back atcha, bud. What is a right, but three lefts?