are we seriously still discussing this play lol
Kincaid is not an option. They're selling the fake TE screen and the reads are Coleman's 9/ Shakir's seam/Cook checkdown, the safety takes Coleman so Shakir is the throw provided he continues his route. If he ever gets to Cook underneath it probably gets zero yards.
its just a bad call and bad design in a very important spot. you're never going to fool a defense w this to get to a super bowl unless you're playing the buffalo bills