Ever heard of one man's trash is another man's treasure?
Or, what works for us may not work for them?
So by your logic, after your 1st relationship didn't work out, you should have been labeled a bust, or not good enough.
Many examples of players in the NFL who are either put in the wrong system, or wrong position, maybe wrong coaching, wrong training, maybe also they haven't matured yet. This guy might be a gem. But you quick to count him out. My question is, why?