I'm still weighing up how much production matters to me. I think that, for the most part, all good players are productive but not all productive players are good. On the All-Time passing yards in a career list for CFB, you have to go down to #10 before you find anyone with a pro career worth talking about (P. Rivers).
The biggest test case for 2017 will be Auburn DE Carl Lawson. Watch him against Laremy Tunsil and you think he'll be a phenom. Look at his stats and it's 18 games, 37 tackles, 10.5 TFL, 5 sacks, 2 FF. At some point, like with Robert Nkemdiche, you have to see talent become production.