Kincaid is actually a much more complete receiver than Gesicki was coming out of the draft. Kuntz is actually the Gesicki comp - an athletic receiving tight end that doesn’t block and basically just runs seam and fade routes.
Kincaid is a player who can go up the seam sure but he also is great at the option routes that kill zone defenses underneath which is why the Kelce comparisons get thrown around (though he is not the athlete Kelce is). He is a pretty complete receiver which is why he is so highly regarded and he will still be a much better blocker than most receivers. He is the only tight end I would have been ok drafting this high because when I was doing my pre-draft review he did all those little things for Utah that Beasley did but with some ability to generate bigger plays up the field. To me the player isn’t in questions, it’s whether he is fully healthy which all reports are he is and whether the Bills give him enough volume.