Yup, you are...because Drew took them to town with a 69 yard pass to Lee Evans. And McGahee is a second half back, he pokes and prods in the first half to find the weaknesses, then exploits them. If McGahee wouldn't have left the game, can you honestly say he wouldn't have taken that defense to the bank in the seconf half? Especially with the Bengals on the ropes? Only reason the Bengals were in the game was because McGahee was out and they knew we couldn't run on them, which is why your argument holds some subtance, but in the end it holds none.