Not really. Reich is such an unknown. Frank has very little control experience. What I mean by that, is that in both spots he was an OC, he was just an accessory and not the main guy.
The one thing that was so great about McDermott is that he was given a lot of freedom in Carolina. I think that showed right away. Everything is so calculated and tight shipped.
Indy needs someone who is going to come in and demand control. I fear that Reich will be too robin and not enough batman.